Home  

“Collateral damage”: The invasion of Ukraine reminds us of the cost of surrogacy, and who pays the price

The term “collateral damage” is used in military contexts with reference to the immunity of non-combatants, in terms of the principle of distinction between civilian and military targets. The use of the term is a recognition that military action has effects, some intended and some not, for which the actors may be held morally and legal responsible. In its more common and more cynical usage, “collateral damage” has become euphemistic code for wanton destruction that is simply shrugged off by those who “can handle the truth”. Since at least the time of the Iraq war, the term no longer commonly refers to the consideration of “unintended damage” — such as in traditional Catholic moral reasoning — but rather to “intended damage” that is calculated and factored into the planning of a military mission. And everyone knows this, even if we don’t always say it out loud.

The international surrogacy industry too is calculated in the damage it inflicts to women’s lives. This is, in part, because the surrogacy system works on a franchise model — in other words, it doesn’t look like a part of global late-capitalism; it looks like the creation of happy families. And these “families” are not presented as what they are: part of the damage and exploitation of global capitalism. Instead, the pictures on surrogacy websites are of glossy people who are said to have taken a “journey”: a “surrogacy journey”.

These pretty pictures, and this pretty language, disguise — indeed, we claim, are intended to disguise — a dirty industry which traffics in women’s lives as well as the lives of newborn babies. It runs parallel to other industries that put a price on the bodies of persons, like the trade in bodily organs, parts, and fluids. But the organ trade is unlawful. The traffic in organs is one of the targets of the UN Global Plan of Action to Combat Trafficking in Persons, with the UN General Assembly’s most recent resolution to combat organ trafficking being adopted in 2018. Few people can be found to defend organ trading.

Not so with surrogacy. The surrogacy journey has a seemingly endless line of philosophers and public health exponents waiting to defend the industry and its practices. One of its most effective rhetorical defences is to refer to what is known as “altruistic surrogacy” as an exemplar of what surrogacy could be like if it were better organised and regulated. But it is just another pretty picture that serves as a screen for an industry based on the commodification of the person: a woman turned into a container for an embryo, whether for payment or expenses. All states and territories in Australia make a distinction in law between commercial and non-commercial surrogacy (except for the Northern Territory, which has no legislation on this question), with the former being unlawful in all states. In the case of New South Wales, Queensland, and the ACT, entering into international commercial agreements for surrogacy is also unlawful and is punishable by a heavy fine and/or gaol. The reality is that altruistic surrogacy — commonly defined as those arrangements in which no money but only the baby changes hands — is simply a wing of the main part of the surrogacy industry.

Women are the collateral damage of the surrogacy industry — not only its unintended damage, but its intended and calculated damage. For the industry and what it calls “clients”, the damage done to the woman who fills the role of “surrogate” is considered as entirely proportionate to the “happy ending” — a new healthy baby — that is the selling point of the industry.

Missing toddler found

Missing toddler found

 

CommentsComments

add bookmarkBookmark

Johannesburg - A toddler who was allegedly sold to a child trafficking syndicate was found on Friday afternoon at a house in Kraaifontein in Cape Town, police said.

The 1-year-old boy, Ovayo Maxetuka from Khayelitsha, was found after police received an anonymous phone call on his whereabouts, said Warrant Officer November Filander.

The boy was in the care of the alleged trafficker's neighbour, said Filander.

"The 41-year-old woman later handed herself over to police at the Kraaifontein police station," he said.

"She will appear in the Khayelitsha Magistrate's Court on Monday, on charges of child trafficking."

Ovayo was last seen on Tuesday. The child's 18-year-old mother discovered he was missing when she returned home from visiting family in Philippi.

She received information that her child had been sold by her mother and a neighbour to a woman believed to be involved in child trafficking.

The 36-year-old grandmother and 43-year-old neighbour were arrested and appeared in the Khayelitsha Magistrate's Court on Friday, where their case was postponed.

They will remain in police custody until October 14.

Baby R Judgement

Baby R Judgement

Forum: "Preet Mandir is asking South African couples for a donation of USD12000

-----Ursprüngliche Nachricht----- Von: JAIA@yahoogroups.com [mailto:JAIA@yahoogroups.com] Im Auftrag von dazichain@aol.com Gesendet: Mittwoch, 26. April 2006 16:10 An: JAIA@yahoogroups.com Betreff: [JAIA] Preet Mandir donations from South Africa "Preet Mandir is asking South African couples for a donation of USD12000 (multiply by 6.20 which is the exchange rate for South African Rand to the Dollar = R74'400) per child. This excludes the South African agency costs and the travelling costs to India. If you adopt twins or siblings the rate is double, that is USD24000. They have also told us that if we cannot pay this donation we should not bother to contact them as they will not consider our application. They also need 50 to 75% of the donation when you submit your application. This has put a huge strain on South African couples as when we did our first adoptions with Preet Mandir the donation required was USD4000 to USD6000 per child. We have approximately 10 couples who are ready to adopt their second child. Unfortunately our local agency does not have contact with any other agencies in India other then Preet Mandir. So it looks like we may not be able to adopt a second child from India. I hope that the above information is useful to you and I hope that we will find another more ethical agency in India that will work with us. We are investigating Shradanand Mahila in Mumbai and we are waiting for them to confirm if they will work with us. Have any of you worked with this agency and what is your feeling about them." YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS § Visit your group "JAIA" on the web. § To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: JAIA-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com § Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.

.

Hague Statistics 2001 - 2003

Hague Statistics 2001 - 2003

Hague Convention enters into Force

Hague Convention enters into Force

Muslims at the Cape want to Romanian orphans provide a better future

DER SPIEGEL 27/1990 of 02.07.1990, page 142

South Africa 

Completely pollute

Muslims at the Cape want to Romanian orphans provide a better future. But the apartheid stands in your way.
The benefactor of the poor, "says the bearded man behind the counter sales of the apparel business," came 500 years into the sky rather than selfish rich. "Mahomed Yusuf Hassim, 52, a strictly devout Muslim who cares so more needy than the future of the small shop on the outskirts of Pretoria, to be from India übergesiedelter grandfather opened 1910.
The pious merchant advocates clemency for death row, or donate money for burial, when in the neighboring township of a black family no decent funeral for a deceased relatives can afford. His love so far as he felt "somewhat apolitical."
Hassims latest project, however, has for Eddy ensured throughout the country and the government of South Africa fallen into a deep embarrassment. On television, he had pictures of the catastrophic conditions in the orphanages of Romania saw and immediately decided to provide legal redress. "My heart was bleeding," says the Muslim, "because I had no choice."
Together with some friends he organized flights initially for 500 children, with adoptive parents in South Africa a better life should be. But the project has doubled in the pitfalls of South African racial laws verheddert. Because Hassim, have become willing to 2000 adoption parents reported that, like the couple and Kulsum Ismail Latief from Cape Town, for the small Ceausescu want to make victims, including many South Africans of Indian descent, but also black and white citizens.
Under the current adoption law, the Child Care Act of 1983, however, parents can only children absorb the same race - white on white, black to black, Indian to Indian. Also belonging to the same religion and culture is an important prerequisite for an adoption. The question of whether Hassim Romanian children in color or black families can bring this divided country and became a test case for reforming the current mood of the government.
A lady Scottish / British ancestry 'disgusted about that in a letter to the Cape Town Argus, that many adoption candidates "are colored or Indian." Of course, those addicted parents, because: "It is a universal truth that we are better with our own kind of things."
As a "ludicrous" and "irresponsible" attack even child carers Hassims plan. "The Orphans", fearing adoption expert in Johannesburg, but AIDS can be infected. " Romania, which everyone knows, is "completely contaminated." Like hardly any other law, the adoption of rules, the absurdity of the apartheid state: children of mixed couples, which made up for adoption, often racially must be reclassified before they can find suitable parents. If a child is even a white parent, is his first appearance by the officials of the social authorities.
Consequently, in South Africa are almost exclusively white children adopted by white families. The large number of black orphans under the law shall no parents, even though white couples would be perfectly willing to accept them.
Even the maintenance rates for orphans are graded according to skin color. Foster parents of white children receive 153 rand (about 100 marks), for Indian children or colored edge 123, for only 70 black rim. The risk of black infants in the first six months of birth to die is six times as high as among white babies.
"Mischievous" cites Noel Zaal, Professor of Private Law, in Durban, the adoption of rules of apartheid - if only because the interests of the child contrary to international practice hintanstehen need. "Unfortunately," says the lawyer, "this law is forcing the parents, also abroad after adoptive babies around."
After some hesitation - in order to avoid conflicts, officials had considered the Romanian children from the beginning of a particular racial assigned - the government now, they measure than whites. All adoption applicants are not white, therefore, have only one chance, if they succeed, the young Romanians later for color or black declare it.
Theoretically this is possible. Every year in South Africa officially, several hundred people and Chinese mestizos, Indians, Blacks or Whites reclassified. The state, however, it did not like, if fair-skinned people "down" can. Most ask for color and black color white to be explained what the authorities sometimes mercifully grant.
In the coming year should also be reformed adoption law, promises trouble in the government. Until then she wants to delay the arrival of the children. A spokesman said that officially had no Hassim of adoption applications received.
The turn is waiting by the authorities of the exact conditions to know for the adoption to families wanting to be able to demand information. "This barbaric act," urged Hassim, "must be lifted immediately." f

Social Worker Busted For Selling Babies

Social Worker Busted For Selling Babies

Monday, April 04, 2011 | Comments: 3

Social worker Sharon Mushokabanji has been busted for selling orphaned children for adoption, reports Jacques Pauw for the City Press.

Mushokabanji has since been dismissed for fraud after it emerged that she had faked her qualifications and registration with the Council for Social Service Professions. She was found by her employer, Child Welfare, to have charged illegal “adoption fees” ranging between R400 and R6,000.

City Press reports that it has obtained paperwork verifying the fraud and that police have launched an investigation into a potential child-trafficking and adoption syndicate. Mushokabanji has denied the charges and even alleged to have information on Child Welfare that she offered the City Press in return for them suppressing the story.

Report Psychological Examination Rahul by Anneke Vinke

Informal translation from Dutch.

 

 

 

Report Psychological Examination