Register Log in

The adoption of children from abroad must be stopped completely for the time being. A committee led by former top civil servant Tjibbe Joustra draws this conclusion in a report to be published, sources around the cabinet report to the AD .

The report on the Dutch adoption culture and the role of the government in it mentions 'serious abuses' in Bangladesh, Brazil, Colombia, Indonesia and Sri Lanka. The committee pointed to child theft, child trafficking, corruption, forgery and theft of documents, unethical acts of civil servants and the transfer of children to the Netherlands under false pretenses. Because today's adoption practice is still not good, bringing children to the Netherlands should stop for the time being, the advice is.

Council of Ministers on report

Friday, the Council of Ministers will talk about the report that will be published on Monday. Not everyone in the government would feel in favor of a complete stop on adoption. The ongoing adoption procedures should go ahead, some believe. A stop should therefore relate to new applications.

Zembla paid attention to abuses in intercountry adoptions in four programs. In response to that broadcast, Minister Dekker said that the “primary responsibility” for a careful adoption procedure lay and lies with the sending countries. But on the basis of later information, Dekker said he saw reason to take a closer look at the actions of the Dutch government.

HOOGE MIERDE - Immediately stopping adoptions of foreign children is a major step that is not necessary. Adoption is and will remain valuable for many children. This is the response of Inez Teurlings, chairman of the Stichting Interlandelijk Geadopterden, to the most important recommendation of the Joustra Committee, which investigated the Dutch adoption practice.

Teurlings, born in Bangladesh and raised in Hooge Mierde, is aware of abuses that are mentioned in the report of the Joustra committee revealed by this newspaper on Friday. Child trafficking, child theft and forging adoption documents, for example.

But such cases mainly took place in the 1970s and 1980s, according to Teurlings. “Then hundreds of children were adopted every year. With such numbers I can imagine that something will go wrong. Nowadays it is still about 125 children per year. ”

Prove

Teurlings emphasizes that she has not yet read the report of the Joustra committee. “I am curious about the evidence of wrongdoing. From our contacts with permit holders who mediate in adoptions, I do not get the impression that much goes wrong. Parties I know are doing well with adoption. ”

A temporary ban on the adoption of children from abroad is a step in the right direction. But it does not give Jyoti Weststrate (37) from Deventer a sense of justice. For Yanien Veenendaal (50) from Apeldoorn, it feels like a small victory.

They let this know in response to the decision by outgoing minister Sander Dekker (Legal Protection) to immediately suspend the adoption of children from abroad. That became known Monday morning.

In the opinion on the Dutch adoption culture and the role of the government in this, reference is made to 'serious abuses'. According to Dekker, the Dutch government has fallen short of looking away from abuses for years. The committee identified child theft, child trafficking, corruption, forgery and theft of documents, unethical acts of civil servants and the transfer of children to the Netherlands under false pretenses.

Presented to a priest

Weststrate was about 2 years old, although she does not rule out the fact that she was older, when she was taken away from her biological parents in India and 'given' to a priest . She ended up in Zutphen, where questions about her origins have been waiting for answers for a lifetime. Now she tries to expose abuses in international adoption.

NEW DELHI: A parliamentary committee in its report on the DNA

Technology (Use and Application) Regulation Bill on Wednesday

suggested the government to "pay very careful attention" to certain views

on very important issues on the proposed legislation, saying some

members have expressed their fears that the bill when it becomes a law

The Dutch Data Protection Authority (AP) has a new advisory board. This now consists of Alexander Pechtold, Marleen Stikker, Eric Tjong Tjin Tai, Jeannine Peek and Tjibbe Joustra. Pechtold is the chairman of the new board.The new advisory board was appointed by Minister of Legal Protection Sander Dekker on the recommendation of the AP on 1 February 2021. Peek and Joustra were also members of the previous advisory board of the AP.The chairman and members are appointed for different periods. In this way, not everyone leaves at the same time and the advisory board can continue.The Advisory Council provides the AP - solicited and unsolicited - with advice on the supervisory authority's mission, vision, ambition and strategy.The members of the AP's advisory board have different backgrounds and positions:Alexander Pechtold (chairman, appointed for 4 years)

Alexander Pechtold has many years of political and administrative experience, including as a Member of Parliament and minister. Since November 2019 he has been general director of the Central Bureau for Driving Licenses (CBR).He is also chairman of the Steering Committee Renovation Binnenhof, member of the supervisory board of the Drents Museum and chairman of the National Purchasing Fund Vereniging Rembrandt.Marleen Stikker (member, appointed for 3 years)

Marleen Stikker is founder and director of Waag Future Lab for design and technology. In addition, she is currently professor of practice at the Hogeschool van Amsterdam, member of the Advisory Council for science, technology and innovation, member of the Amsterdam Economic Board, co-founder and board member of Public Spaces and chair of the Consultative Body for the Physical Environment.In 2019 Marleen Stikker wrote the book 'The internet is broken'.Eric Tjong Tjin Tai (member, appointed for 3 years)

Eric Tjong Tjin Tai is Professor of Private Law at Tilburg University. He is chairman of the Cassation Commission in the interests of the law. And deputy judge at the Netherlands Commercial Court.Jeannine Peek (member, appointed for 2 years)

Jeannine Peek (photo) is General Manager of Dell Technologies Netherlands. She is also a figurehead ICT for the Top Sector ICT, board member of the NL Digital sector association and the National Register Foundation (on behalf of VNO-NCW), member of the supervisory board of the Internet Domain Registration Foundation Netherlands and ambassador for the University of Twente.Tjibbe Joustra (member, appointed for 1 year)

The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Science and Technology, Environment, Forests and Climate Change has recommended that the government assuage concerns raised over the DNA Technology (Use and Application) Regulation Bill, 2019, including over creation of a national databank of crime scene DNA profiles and fears of communities being targeted.

While recognising the importance of DNA technology in criminal investigation, the committee, in its report tabled in Parliament Wednesday, says, “The risk with a national databank of crime scene DNA profiles is that it will likely include virtually everyone since DNA is left at the ‘crime scene’ before and after the crime by several persons who may have nothing to do with the crime being investigated.”

It adds, “These fears (regarding the Bill) are not entirely unfounded (and) have to be recognized and addressed by the government and by Parliament as well… The Committee is of the strong opinion that an enabling ecosystem must be created soon to ensure that DNA profiling is done in a manner that is fully consistent with the letter and spirit of various Supreme Court judgments and with the Constitution.”

First proposed in 2003, the Bill has gone through several revisions, by both the Department of Biotechnology and Law Ministry. It was referred to the Parliamentary Standing Committee in October 2019, soon after it was passed. A number of MPs who deposed before the panel repeated fears — expressed by members earlier too — that the Bill could be misused to target segments of society based on religion, caste or political views.

The panel’s report says, “The Committee is conscious of the fact that this Bill is very technical, complex and sensitive. A number of Members have expressed concern about the use of DNA technology — or more accurately its misuse — to target different segments of our society based on factors like religion, caste or political views. These fears are not entirely unfounded (and) have to be recognized and addressed.”

LEO VARADKAR HAS told the Dáil he was “quite surprised” to hear that audio recordings of witness testimony given to the Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes were destroyed.

His comments come amid calls for Children’s Minister Roderic O’Gorman to “take immediate action” to preserve the testimony of witnesses who gave evidence to the commission.

A number of campaigners and opposition TDs have also called for the commission to not be dissolved as planned at the end of the month amid concerns of the deletion of audio recording of testimony.

They say the commission should remain in operation until its members answer questions about its final report, as well as the destruction of audio recordings of witness testimony.

Varadkar said O’Gorman is examining if it “makes sense” to extend the term of the commission so these issues can be examined.

The adoption file of Doriet Begemann (41) from Zwolle is full of mistakes. "I take into account that I have been stolen and resold."

Doriet, like thousands of other adoptees, desperately searches for her origins.

The question is whether the Dutch government played a role in illegal adoptions between 1967 and 1998. An investigation committee will hand over a report to Minister Sander Dekker (Legal Protection) on Monday. Civil servants may have been involved , he writes when he establishes the committee in 2018.

The committee examined adoptions from countries including Bangladesh, Brazil, Sri Lanka, Colombia and Indonesia.

DORIET

No love, no human contact, languishing and forgotten in the home: Under the Romanian dictator Nicolae Ceau?escu, babies who did not fit the norm were mercilessly sorted out. Whats become of you?

Izidor spent the first three years of his life in the hospital.

The dark-eyed, dark-haired boy, born June 20, 1980, was abandoned when he was a few weeks old. The reason for this was obvious to all who looked: His right leg was twisted. After an illness (probably polio) he had been thrown into the sea of ??abandoned infants in the Socialist Republic of Romania.

In films from the period that capture the care of orphans, nurses are seen like assembly line workers wrapping newborns from a seemingly endless supply; with muscular arms and careless indifference, they toss the children onto a square cloth, expertly knot it into a neat bundle, and place it at the end of a line of silent, worried-looking babies. The women do not speak softly to them or sing to them. You can see the little faces trying to understand what is happening as their heads roll back and forth during the winding manoeuvre.

At his hospital in Sighetu Marma?iei, a mountain town in northern Romania, Izidor was probably fed with a bottle placed in his mouth and propped against the bars of his cot. Well past the age when children in the outer world begin to taste solid foods and then eat for themselves, he and his peers remained on their backs, sucking from bottles whose openings had been widened to allow watery gruel to flow through. Without proper care or physical therapy, the baby's leg muscles atrophied. At the age of three he was found "deficient" and transferred to the other side of town to a C?min Spital Pentru Copii Deficien?i , a home for unsavable children.


Adoptions

Child abuse, Bulgaria condemned: "Reports from Italian judges ignored"

by Fabrizio Gatti February 4, 2021

According to the European Court of Human Rights, Sofia did not investigate. And the role of the Milanese association Aibi in creating "an atmosphere of conflict" that did not favor the investigation is central

The reports of abuse transmitted by the Italian judiciary should not have been immediately archived. The shocking testimonies of three children, who had suffered atrocious sexual violence together with other children of the same age in a Bulgarian orphanage , were credible and detailed. The children had begun to confide in the psychologists appointed by the adoptive family, after their adoption in Italy concluded in 2012 with the mediation of the association “Aibi – Amici dei bambini” of Milan. And they had then confirmed their words before the public prosecutor of a Juvenile Prosecutor's Office who, following international procedures, had transmitted the documents to Sofia. The judicial file described children who had also been raped by adults, who on some occasions had filmed the attacks.

For this reason, on 2 February the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights condemned Bulgaria , upholding the appeal against an initial decision of the Court that had rejected the appeal of the adoptive parents. According to the majority of judges, the Sofia authorities "who did not avail themselves of the available investigations and international cooperation mechanisms, did not take all reasonable measures to shed light on the case and did not carry out a complete and careful analysis of the evidence submitted to them. The omissions observed", explains a note from the European Court, "appeared sufficiently serious to consider that the investigation carried out was not effective in accordance with the purposes of Article 3 of the Convention, interpreted in the light of other international provisions and in particular the Lanzarote Convention".

INHUMAN AND DEGRADING TREATMENTS
According to the Grand Chamber, Bulgaria has therefore violated the European Convention on Human Rights, which in Article 3 establishes that "no one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment". Even more so if the children were under ten years old at the time. The Bulgarian State will therefore have to compensate the three children , assisted by the lawyer Francesco Mauceri, within three months with a total sum of thirty-six thousand euros.

The judges, also due to the lack of in-depth investigations, do not maintain that the reported violence actually occurred and that therefore there was a violation of the substantial part of Article 3. Instead, they establish that Bulgaria violated the procedural part that should have ascertained the possible substantial violation of the same article. A principle that concerns the States, which however must not be deprived of the full collaboration of the intermediation associations that, in international adoptions, operate with the authorization and on behalf of the respective governments.

THE THEORY DICTED BY MILAN
Among the ninety-eight pages of reasons , the non-appealable judgment of the Grand Chamber dedicates entire paragraphs to the conduct of the association Aibi-Amici dei bambini , which is based in San Giuliano Milanese and is supported by famous testimonials from the world of politics, entertainment and sports. "The conclusion of the Grand Chamber", note in a joint opinion judges Turkovi?, Pinto de Albuquerque, Bošnjak and the Italian Raffaele Sabato, "could be integrated, in our view, by the consideration that the reasoning adopted by the Bulgarian judicial authorities and by the State Agency for Child Protection substantially reaffirmed the theory advanced by the association that had acted as an intermediary for the adoption".

“The representatives of that association,” the judges explained, referring to Aibi, “when the adoptive parents approached them after the first disclosure of the abuse, began to express the opinion that the parents were not suitable to adopt the children, on the basis of their behaviour during a meeting organised by the association on 2 October 2012. The Court was unable to ascertain whether the report on this meeting between the association’s staff, the parents and the children was authentic, given that… the applicants produced a police report stating that three representatives of the association had to provide proof of their signature, and acknowledged that the report bears three different signatures, all written by the same hand.”

THE RETOUCHED REPORT
“Furthermore,” the judges of the Grand Chamber noted, “the report apparently showed discrepancies in the text, in the form of additions and deletions, which the Court was unable to verify. Regardless of whether the Bulgarian authorities knew from the beginning about this alleged forgery, it appears clear to us that the forgery of the document was discussed by the applicants before the Grand Chamber without the Government responding on the point. This circumstance, together with the fact that the association met with representatives of the various authorities involved... and drafted a highly critical report on the adoptive parents' account, which it then transmitted to the Juvenile Court... testifies to the central role played by the association in creating an atmosphere of conflict which did not favour the initiation of effective investigations".

"The Court", the judges continue in the judgment, still referring to Aibi, "also regretted thatthe association that acted as intermediary for the adoption with the authorities of the respondent State, had sent a note to the Court in which it expressed the opinion that the parents were unsuitable as adoptive parents because – in the opinion of the association – they had triggered a process of denunciation of abuses that did not exist , with the aim of denigrating the procedure that had led to the adoption. The content of this decision, in our opinion, reinforces the idea that the minors' revelations were credible, and [therefore] the association's approach was officially rejected».

IT WAS NOT PREMATURE SEXUALITY
The orphanage of horrors was reported in an investigation by L'Espresso and subsequently closed. The Aibi association, which operates under the authorization of the Italian government, did not respond to our request for comment.

«A final observation», conclude the judges of the Grand Chamber, «must be made, in our opinion, regarding the consideration that the events were a “simple” phenomenon of precocious sexuality, due to the fact that the children live together in an orphanage. According to this point of view, consequently there was no need to investigate, since only the minors were responsible for the sexual contacts and no criminal liability could be attributed to them. First, we note once again that this was the theory supported by the association that acted as an intermediary in the adoption», highlight the judges of the Grand Chamber of the Strasbourg Court, always referring to Aibi: «Second, there were reports, even in the first disclosures, of violent sexual contacts initiated by minors. In this regard, we must underline that also important international norms consider violence inflicted by peers as violence against minors and that in these cases the criminal liability does not lie with the violent children, but with those who have the task of supervising and caring for them».

POLICE REPORT
The prosecutor's office and the juvenile court, which had deemed the complaint of the three children credible, also established the full suitability of the adoptive parents, who, according to the Strasbourg Court, Aibi had defined as unsuitable. But as happened in Bulgaria, the Italian judiciary that deals with the behavior of adults has archived all the numerous complaints filed over the years against the Milanese association, for alleged irregularities in the adoption procedures .

The same police report that in Rome attested to the "three different signatures, all written by the same hand" ended up in the archives: they appear at the bottom of the report delivered to the juvenile court by the top management of Aibi, who at that time were acting before the judicial authority in their capacity as an entity authorized by the Italian government. This is the unusual reason why an ordinary public prosecutor requested and obtained the archiving: "The false signature on the report produced by Aibi to the Juvenile Court remains to be considered [...]. The only crime that can be configured in this sense, since it is a party act, is the falsity of a private document no longer provided for by law as a crime."