Home  

Remembering Naomi Bronstein: A Homegrown Activist for Children Worldwide






Full Length Article:
Remembering Naomi Bronstein: A Homegrown Activist for Children Worldwide 
By Brendan Cavanaugh, Secretary-General of TDH Canada
Published January 2011

Description: Naomi Bronstein and two children

Index of Articles


  1. Remembering Naomi Bronstein: A Homegrown Activist for Children Worldwide
    Excerpt / Full version

  2. Kon Tum & the Central Highlands
    Excerpt / Full version

  3. The List
    Full version

  4. An Important Update on the Process of Child Proposals from Vietnam
    Full version

  5. Terre des hommes (TDH) Founder Edmund Kaiser
    Excerpt / Full version

  6. Memories of Vietnam
    Excerpt / Full version

Naomi Bronstein was a hands-on, do-it-herself activist for children. She established orphanages in Vietnam, Cambodia and Guatemala. She was running a mobile medical clinic for rural children in Guatemala when she went to sleep on December 23, 2010 and died during the night. She had poor health including heart disease for a number of years and her heart finally gave out. She was 65.
Her death marks the beginning of the end of an era. She was part of the social phenomenon in Montreal that initiated and developed international adoption in Canada.
A Child of the Times
North America in the late 50s to early 70s was the era of the Beatles, President Jack Kennedy and Rev. Martin Luther King, Pierre Elliot Trudeau, and most pervasive of all, it was the era of the amorphous spirit of the youth-inspired Peace Movement which promoted many other things, some of them good, some of them not-so-good. Among the good was a concern for racial equality and global responsibility. Mottoes like ‘Make Love, not War!’ and ‘We are the Human Family!’ were everywhere. Books were being published threatening a future of overcrowding and scarcity of food. The war in Vietnam produced an awareness of war-orphaned and war-wounded children. All those things combined to produce a social attitude out of which arose the idea in the mind of many couples that both having children and adopting children would be a good thing and some couples took the concrete action of exploring international adoption.

Experience the difference

Experience the difference

By Kristin Morency, The Suburban
 




Photo by Martin Chamberland, The Suburban

Chamandy: It’s important to promote the creativity of artists.

 



Gift store sells crafts from Africa, South America, Mexico and Canada.


 

It’s hard to imagine that shopping here at home could benefit destitute orphans on the other side of the world.

Vive la Différence, a small gift shop on Monkland Ave. in N.D.G., is a non-profit, volunteer-run store founded and operated by Beaconsfieldresident Tina Chamandy. 

Net profits are sent to Families for Children (FFC),  a non-profit Canadian organization providing support and care for women and children in two orphanages in India and Bangladesh.  

The store, which promotes fair trade and features unique crafts from artists around the world, has been open for about a year. 

Chamandy works alone, although sometimes her friends volunteer. 

On top of supporting FFC, Chamandy’s goal with Vive la Différence is to promote fair trade.

“I like to provide an alternative to the usual mass-produced items we find everywhere,” Chamandy said at her store last week.

“I’m a strong believer in fair trade. And I think it’s important to promote the creativity of artists all over the world and in Canada, and to enrich the lives of consumers and expose them to the diversity and beauty of the world.” 

Fine handcrafted glassware, original ceramics, purses, furniture and costume jewellery from Africa, South America, Mexico and Canada, can be found in Chamandy’s store.

Photos of some of the approximately 225 children from the two FFC orphanages hang on the store’s walls, and pamphlets about the orphans are available at the cash.

Chamandy, a mother of five who opened the store with her husband after they retired, has visited the children at the orphanage in Indiathree times.

“They’re extremely warm. They call you ‘Mommy’ and ‘Daddy,’” she said. “They’re always smiling and they were so excited to see us the first time we came. My heart melts for them.”

The orphanage in India spans a couple of town blocks and includes a small school, a library, and sleeping quarters. 

FFC receives children who are abandoned or referred to them by Indian social services. 

Occasionally, a family will bring their children to the orphanage if they’re too poor to look after them, but the kids will return home for holidays.

According to Chamandy, some of the orphans have physical disabilities or are infected with H.I.V.  

Nonetheless, many of the kids and women who are at the orphanages produce items, like cards and silk purses, to be sold in her store.

Above a shelf holding cards with intricate needlework, Chamandy points to a photograph of a visually impaired boy hard at work on one of the cards that will end up in her store. 

She said he didn’t want to wear glasses because he was afraid of how they made him look, so he had to hold the paper really close to his face to perfect his needlepoint.

“It shows that no matter how destitute or badly off they are, they’re still people,” Chamandy said.

Chamandy became involved with FFC when she was trying to adopt a child from Vietnam. (She ended up adopting a girl from Thailand who’s now 26 years-old.)

While going through the adoption process, she met Sandra Simpson, the founder of FFC.

“I’ve known Sandra a very long time and have been a supporter ever since,” said Chamandy.

Simpson, a native of Colombia who has homes in Pointe Claire and Toronto, said she adopted 24 children and has eight biological ones.

Along with her friends Bonnie Cappuccino and Naomi Bronstein, in 1968 Simpson founded FFC when she adopted a child from Vietnam. 

“Because of the publicity and requests from other people wanting to do the same, I founded FFC to help people adopt,” she said.

Since then, FFC has developed from an adoption agency to having in-country care centres in India and Bangladesh.

“I believe all of us are born for a reason, and that reason if possible should be to help another. I feel very fortunate in being part of an organization that helps so many,” Simpson said.

“Tina is doing an incredible job,” added Simpson. “She’s working so hard without any staff and she herself does not take pay. Being a small charity that gets very little publicity, awareness is very important to us.”

Vive la Différence is located at 5525 Monkland Ave. Hours are 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Tuesday to Friday, 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Saturday, and noon to 5 p.m. Sunday. 

2006-10-25 09:55:39

New Legislation will bring more transparency for parents wanting to adopt in Flanders

Waiting for my child

New legislation will bring more transparency to parents wanting to adopt in Flanders

Eight to 10 years. That’s how long prospective adoptive parents in Flanders have to wait for a child to arrive in their family.

When the adoption agencies made these numbers public last year, it sent a shockwave through the adoption landscape. The number of candidates fell drastically, put off by the waiting time. Kind & Gezin, the government agency responsible for family issues, including adoption, recently came up with new numbers. The average waiting period is four years, the agency said. Ten years is really a worst-case scenario. But four years is still quite a while to wait. Why does it take so long?

“There are a number of steps candidates have to go through,” explains Else De Wachter, a Flemish MP for the socialist party and one of the driving forces behind the new legislation. “They have to be investigated by an agency, and a judge has to declare the parents suitable, which also takes some time.” Where the child is coming from can also make a difference. “The countries of origin often need plenty of time to declare children eligible for adoption and appropriate them,” says De Wachter.

And most adoptions in Brussels and Flanders are indeed international. Cases of Flemish children being adopted are usually familial – a stepparent or grandparents adopting a child. Few Flemish children are put up for adoption to outside families, and the conditions to adopt a Flemish child are even more difficult to meet.

Interests of the child above all

International adoptions often deliver children with special needs, but De Wachter says this is generally not a problem for local parents. “On the contrary,” she says. “What those needs are depends on the country of origin – they all use different definitions. The child may have a small disability or bigger problems. Either way, the parents have to make a conscious decision. We have to be careful that people do not apply for children with needs they cannot cope with simply because they believe they are easier to adopt.”

Rather, what causes the shortage of children is a greater awareness in many countries that children are best raised within their own communities. For this reason, the number of adoptees dropped by 16% in 2010, with sharp decreases from Ethiopia, Russia and Kazakhstan (which stopped its co-operation altogether).

At the same time, it is hard to find new countries of origin – or “channels”, as they are known – because of the high ethical demands by the Flemish authorities. De Wachter: “Above all, we respect the Hague Treaty, which states that the child’s interests prevail. This means that children are best looked after by their own families, in their countries of origin. In case of orphaned or abandoned children, an investigation has to be launched to find relatives.”

With over 600 candidates deemed suitable as adoptive parents and only 120 adoptions in 2011, long waiting periods are unavoidable. The new legislation, which was voted in the Flemish Parliament last month and will come into effect as of 2013, aims to offer more transparency to prospective adoptive parents. “If they know from the start a procedure might take up to 10 years, they can make a more informed decision,” says De Wachter.

The waiting game

De Wachter is in fact a prospective parent herself. “I was told that the procedure takes an average of one-and-a-half to two years, but I’ve been waiting now for six. The adoption should be in its final stages right now, but, with so many obstacles, you can only be sure once the child has arrived in the family.”

You have to be realistic, she continues. “When you start a procedure, you should know that the international context changes all the time. Not everything can be predicted, but some things can be taken into account. Therefore, the new legislation introduces an intake control: Everyone can still apply for adoption, but the procedure starts only when there is a prospect [of getting a child] in, say, three years.”

Flanders will also become more pro-active in opening more channels through which children arrive. “Flanders does not co-operate with some countries that Wallonia does. Surely there must be some possibilities there,” says De Wachter. “The procedure to recognise new channels was previously not very clear. Adoption agencies would spend a lot of time and effort to find new channels, only to see them rejected. The new legislation will provide a set time period for this investigation, with motivations to come to a conclusion.”

Whether this will result in more adoptions in a few years’ time is hard to predict. Clearly, adoption is not the answer for all families hoping for children, so the only message to prospective parents is that they should think an application through. De Wachter: “An adoption is not something you decide on at the age of 20. Most adoptive parents are 30 or more before they apply. This means the parents might be 40 by the time the child arrives. Will their families still be capable of raising a child at this stage? Personally, I believe they are, but that is a decision everyone has to make for themselves.”

Finally, the legislation offers more rights to the adoptees themselves: They are more closely followed up and have easier access to their files should they want to trace back where they came from. “We wanted to offer more legal security to prospective parents, but also to the adoptees,” says De Wachter.

www.adoptievlaanderen.be

 

Reunited in Zedelgem

Teena and Wine were best friends in an orphanage in Calcutta before they were both adopted and lost touch. In an unlikely stroke of luck, both girls ended up with parents in Zedelgem, West Flanders. The parents had no idea of the girls’ special bond, until they fell into each others’ arms four years ago on Wine’s first day at the school Teena had attended for some months. The girls, then five and six, picked up their friendship, even though Teena had learned Dutch by then and mostly forgotten Bengali, the language Wine still spoke. Now they are inseparable, and are much like sisters.

Witness

Lieve Van Bastelaere, adoptive parent

Journalist Lieve Van Bastelaere writes a weekly column for Het Laatste Nieuws on life with her newly adopted son, Tamru. She had to wait five years for her son to arrive, but her experience with adoption was mostly positive.

“My husband and I already had a son when we decided to adopt. In the application, we put no preference as to the sex of the child. That means you will probably get a boy, we were told, because most candidates prefer girls; apparently they suffer less racism here. We preferred a child younger than five-and-a-half years old, so that he could attend preschool for at least one year before going to first grade. Children who are older often have to remain in the orphanages because adoptive parents prefer babies. We wanted to give one of those children a chance, too. We also said that the child could have a minor disability – which in the end he did not.

Our son’s country of origin is Ethiopia. We did not have much of a choice, for multiple reasons. Some countries ask for a medical certificate proving the parents’ infertility – hardly a possibility in our situation. Others require that the adoptive parents be religious, which we are not. Ethiopia has some advantages, though. At the time, for instance, you only needed to travel over once for an adoption.

I have mixed feelings about the suitability of the screening we underwent. I firmly believe that screenings are necessary. An adoptive child is difficult to cope with, and parents need to be strong, especially when the child is older or has special needs. Still, I wonder how any screening can be adequate. How can you possibly find out if someone is fit to raise a child?

I especially disliked the questions they asked my other son, who was five at the time. ‘What do you not like about your mother and father? Can you show us the house?’ What questions to ask a five-year-old!

We got a positive result straightaway, though. Once you have a positive court ruling, there is not much you can do but wait. Our name was put on a list – on the bottom of page three.

Our son has been here for one year now. When he first arrived, he was very anxious, which we had expected. For months, he did nothing but scream and hardly slept at night. He was very aggressive towards his brother and towards me, all of which stems from fear of abandonment. Now Tamru is a normal five-year-old and doing well at school. Gradually, the screaming stopped. Now we get plenty of hugs and kisses. Really, it’s wonderful.”

(February 8, 2012

'Gang sold babies to couples in Haryana'

'Gang sold babies to couples in Haryana'

Dwaipayan Ghosh, TNN Feb 5, 2012, 02.55AM ISTTags:

Vasant Kunj police|station house officer

NEW DELHI: Cops have been forced to cast their nets wider after the abused teenager shed light on a baby boy, who was also probably sold off in the name of adoption. In this regard, a new name has cropped up, Nikki.

 

Officials examine inter-country adoption of Lao children

Officials examine inter-country adoption of Lao children

Lao government officials and representatives of international organisations learned about inter-country adoption yesterday to ensure all Lao children retain their full rights if adopted in other countries.

Professor Ket Kiettisack (centre left) and Mr Tim Schaffter (centre right) address the meeting.

Deputy Minister of Justice Professor Ket Kiettisack said the government welcomed the adoption of Lao children by people living in other countries, but it should be ensured the children have full rights after adoption.

“Adopted children should be able to visit their birth parents in their home country,” Professor Ket said at the opening ceremony of the Orientation on Inter-Country Adoption, held in Vientiane.

Laos: Officer Questioned For Trafficking In Babies

Laos: Officer Questioned For Trafficking In Babies

Written by: Eurasia Review

February 6, 2012

A retired justice ministry officer in Laos has been hauled up for questioning after he “adopted” newborn babies from hospitals and poor rural households and allegedly sold them—mostly to Americans, Canadians, and Australians, according to government officials.

The officer, who obtained adoption papers from the justice and foreign affairs ministries for babies that had been taken away from their parents, is accused of selling the infants—all one to two years old—for U.S. $1,500 to $5,000 each.

Laos probes sale of babies to Australians

Laos probes sale of babies to Australians
by: From correspondents in Hanoi
From: AFP
February 06, 20127:55PM

LAOS is investigating a retired justice ministry official for allegedly selling adopted babies to Australians, Americans and Canadians for thousands of dollars each.

The official is accused of seeking out unwanted babies in poor rural areas, obtaining adoption papers and selling the infants to foreigners for up to $5,000 each, according to a Radio Free Asia report today.

He has been taken in for questioning.

Laos has suspended foreign adoptions pending the outcome of the investigation.

Adoption law to help children of married parents

Adoption law to help children of married parents

CARE: Call for more flexible system

By Alan O'Keeffe

Monday January 30 2012

CHILDREN of married parents will be allowed to be voluntarily adopted under new legislation planned by the Government.

Currently, the only way a child of married parents can be adopted by others is if the parents have been legally deemed to have failed or are likely to fail in their duties of care for the child.

Minister for Children Frances Fitzgerald said large numbers of children of married parents who could have been adopted in the past were barred from being adopted because of the Constitution.

The upcoming Children's Rights Referendum to change the Constitution will be accompanied by new laws allowing children of married parents to be adopted, she said.

Children of unmarried parents do not face the same hurdles when it comes to adoption. A mother who is not married can voluntarily give their child up for adoption.

Currently, married parents do not have that option and the new laws are intended to introduce more flexibility into the system to improve the care options for children.

 

Cost

Meanwhile, efforts to speed up the system for people seeking to adopt children from foreign countries are under way. Prospective parents may be asked to make a financial contribution to the cost of assessments regarding their suitability.

The Health Service Executive (HSE) has been criticised for long delays in the assessment process and extra financing may allow these tasks to be outsourced to outside agencies.

The Adoption Act 2010 enables the HSE to use outside agencies to do assessment work but so far there has been no outsourcing of these functions.

The Adoption Authority has stated in recent months that there were a number of factors influencing the numbers of inter-country adoptions, including increasing delays by the (HSE) in assessing people's suitability.

Child protection here is its priority so adoption is not hugely resourced.

There has been a fall off in people proceeding with adoption because of the recession, while some were waiting to see if more countries would open up to Irish people.

Russia accounted for the largest proportion -- some 38pc -- of all adoptions into Ireland between 1991 and 2010.

aokeeffe@herald.ie

- Alan O'Keeffe

Agency closure puts prospective parents on hold

Agency closure puts prospective parents on hold



Ben and Ruth Veurink are waiting to adopt a seven-year-old boy from Africa.

Ben and Ruth Veurink are waiting to adopt a seven-year-old boy from Africa.

Updated:  Fri Feb. 03 2012 17:28:29



ctvcalgary.ca

 

A Manitoba based adoption agency is shutting down and now several Alberta families are worried about the welfare of the children and the status of their adoptions.

 

The Canadian Advocate for the Adoption of Children or CAFAC, says it can no longer afford to maintain its overseas operations and closed its doors on Friday.

 

The agency held one of the few licences in Canada that allows people to legally and ethically adopt children from Ethiopia.

In a statement CAFAC says because of funding issues with the Manitoba government it will be unable to "continue provision of services beyond February 3rd."

 

CAFAC wants the Manitoba government to allow it to charge clients higher fees.

 

Costs for international adoptions are regulated, but the fee structure varies widely between provinces.

In 2010, the Manitoba government increased fees by $3,000, which made it more difficult for organizations like CAFAC to stay in business.

Ben and Ruth Veurink are just weeks away from completing the adoption process.

 

They are scheduled to fly to Africa in three weeks to file adoption papers with the court.

 

The couple has been working for nearly two years to adopt Tessama, a seven-year-old Ethiopian boy.

 

The Veurink's hope that the adoption won't go off the rails and say they are not getting any help from CAFAC.

 

"I've tried to talk to CAFAC, they're not responding to any questions so I'm just dealing now with the people in Africa that have our seven-year-old child," said Ruth Veurink.

 

The Manitoba government says it is working with the defunct adoption agency to get things back on track.

 

 

 

The money paid by families affected by the closure is currently being held in trust.

(With files from ctv.ca)

Adopting families keep watch on financially strapped agency


Adopting families keep watch on financially strapped agency
The Dewald family, from left, Josiah, 15, Erika 7, dad Evan, mom Christin and Caroline, 8, greet Otto, who they adopted from Ethopia, for the first...more
BY STEPHANE MASSINON AND BRYAN WEISMILLER, CALGARY HERALD FEBRUARY 5, 2012

A Medicine Hat family is closely watching the last-ditch efforts to help save a Manitoba-based international adoption agency from going under.

The Veurink family is in the process of adopting a seven-year-old boy from Ethiopia through the Canadian Advocate For the Adoption of Children (CAFAC) agency but learned recently they are having significant money problems.

In a note posted on its website, the agency said it was going to end its services on Feb. 3 but decided to hold an emergency meeting Saturday in an attempt to keep the agency running.

“We want to assure you that our operations in Ethiopia are continuing, the children are being cared for, the files continue to proceed, your funds remain in trust accounts,” reads the CAFAC letter.

The agency says in recent months there has been a drastic decrease in the amount of referrals coming from Ethiopia to the agency. Whereas they used to receive five per month, there have been only seven referrals since July.

With fewer possible adoptions and lengthier wait times, the agency found itself tight on cash.

Ruth Veurink says her two-year adoption process is almost done and she has a court date in Ethiopia in the next two weeks to begin the adoption process for the boy, Tessema.

If approved in court, the next step is to await all official paperwork.

“These kids are in the foster home awaiting the adoptions. CAFAC has indicated that they will only be cared for until the end of February financially,” she said on Saturday from her Medicine Hat home.

If needed, she says she will stay in Ethiopia and care for the boy until she can legally bring him home and said that wait time could be two months long.

“CAFAC has been very supportive throughout the whole process but now we’re left in the dark. We can’t get hold of anyone. We e-mail them and we don’t hear back,” she said.

On Saturday, she anxiously awaited news about the fate of the organization.

Evan Dewald also expressed concern about losing the agency over the weekend.

A father of two Ethiopian children adopted through CAFAC, Dewald said he feels for families currently trying to adopt from Ethiopia.

“We would be devastated,” said Dewald, adding overseas adoptions take years and thousands of dollars.

“You can imagine being three years into the process. . . . Emotionally, for a lot of people it’s like having a miscarriage,” he said.

Dewald, a Chestermere resident, is one of many Canadians circulating a petition through social media. He hopes the agency gets additional funding.

“There are people here dying to adopt a child,” he said.

In January, CAFAC trimmed its staff from eight to three to save money. It also added a file maintenance fee of $1,000 per year.

However, on Feb. 1 the agency said it could not get sufficient financial help from the Manitoba government and started a last-ditch letter writing campaign to convince officials to help.

Since 1997, CAFAC has completed over 700 adoptions.

smassinon@calgaryherald.com

bweismiller@calgaryherald.com