Home  

Request_members_questions_adoption.pdf

On Thursday 11 February, the House of Representatives will discuss this with the Joustra Committee

the abuses in intercountry adoption. The conclusions from the report of the

commission are firm. For many adopted children from the period before 1998 this is

report confirming the fact that there have been terrible wrongs

took place and the apologies that the government has made are very empty

'Time for thorough reflection on adoption'

The Netherlands decided yesterday, after a damning report, to suspend intercountry adoptions. Flanders does not want to do the same helplessly.

The Dutch government has immediately decided to suspend adoptions of children from abroad. Candidate families that are well advanced in the procedure can still continue with it. The decision follows a damning report by the Joustra Commission, which concludes that abuses from the past have still not been completely resolved and that the Dutch government has looked away for years.

The report had already been leaked on Friday, but was officially presented on Monday. Adoptees here also eagerly looked forward to this and the response from the Dutch government.

Happy surprise

"I didn't expect this decision so soon, but it's a happy surprise," says San-Ho Correwyn, 51, co-author of the recently released book Feeling Adopted . 'I have also cherished the hope for a long time that Belgium and my country of origin Korea will do the same, and hit mea culpa. Intercountry adoption doesn't exactly have a clean history. '

They are not surprised by the criticism of adoption: 'A child was regularly given a name that was invented on the spot'

The adoption of children from abroad has been temporarily suspended, following harsh criticism from the Joustra Commission. Marijke Bleijenberg worked in a children's home in China and is not surprised, as is Antony Vinke, who discovered errors in his own adoption file.

'Even before this research report brought it to light, I was already aware that adopted adoption procedures are not always correct. My own adoption papers also contain errors and forgeries, 'says Antony Vinke (34). His parents adopted him as a baby from Sri Lanka. He doesn't blame them, he emphasizes. 'They have acted in good conscience and conscience. I am now happy with my family in the Netherlands. But if no mistakes had been made in Sri Lanka, I probably wouldn't have ended up here. '

'A mess', is how Vinke summarizes the papers that his parents received upon his transfer. "For example, the medical document said I was a girl." In 2016, when he was 29 years old, he decided to look for his biological parents in his native country.

He received the assistance of a Sri Lankan who is an expert in such quests. 'I ended up on an emotional rollercoaster. You start with the basic information you have, but in the hospital where I was born I saw my name, but the name of my biological mother was missing. ' Then they tracked down a couple whose husband had the same surname as stated on Vinke's papers. 'It turned out that he had a son from 1986, but he lived in Sri Lanka. So that trail also ended. '

Vinke had a photo of the woman who gave it up. Its publication in the national newspaper in Sri Lanka resulted in a reaction from a woman, but her story did not match what Vinke knew about the transfer at the court at the time.

Vlogging in search of biological parents

Muniz Dekker was adopted from the city 26 years ago. From Brazil he came to live in Eenrum when he was two. Now Dekker is looking for his biological parents. He takes us on his quest through vlogs.

Dekker accurately keeps track of all his steps in the search for his biological parents. He makes extensive vlogs about this . Despite being adopted 26 years ago, he started his search and his vlogs last December. And that is not without reason.

'I thought it was too confrontational'

'Eleven months ago I became a father to a daughter and since then my interest has been rekindled. I have worked on it a few times in the past, but that came to nothing and then I stopped looking. I also found it too confronting, not knowing what I would encounter. '

Quest for little daughter

3,000+ couples waiting, but only 100 kids up for adoption

Adoption numbers have fallen over the past year, mainly because of new challenges created by

the pandemic.

“It is not a drastic drop, but it is signicant enough,” says a member of the Integrated Child Protection

Scheme (ICPS), set up by the central government to provide protection for children in difcult

circumstances.

Informatie over onderzoek naar interlandelijke adoptie / Information about research into intercountry adoption

On Monday, February 8, 2021 it is report 'Committee on the investigation of intercountry adoption'published and handed over to Minister of Legal Protection, Sander Dekker. This report is the result of an independent investigation by the 'Committee on the Investigation of Intercountry Adoption in the Past' into the actual course of events surrounding old international adoptions and the role of the Dutch government in this.

What is now known?

Minister Dekker indicates that the Dutch government has failed to act for years by looking away from abuses in international adoptions and not intervening in this. This applies at least for the period 1967-1998.

In the past, the Dutch government has acted too passively in intercountry adoptions, had insufficient supervision of adoption procedures and did not intervene in cases of abuses that came to light. Mediating bodies operating in the Netherlands were also aware of abuses, but did not intervene.

All international adoption procedures will be suspended immediately. This has been decided because the current adoption system still contains vulnerabilities and cannot be controlled sufficiently.

Cabinet receives report on adoption from abroad

The cabinet will receive the research report on adoption from abroad on Monday. After reporting from the AD on Friday, insiders said that the Commission for the Investigation of Intercountry Adoption, led by Tjibbe Joustra, advises to stop adopting children from abroad altogether. Too many abuses would have come to light to be able to proceed responsibly.

It is not yet certain whether the cabinet will fully adopt the recommendations from the investigation report. According to insiders, this is still being discussed, partly because of the question of whether current proceedings may still be completed.

Dutch officials may have been involved in illegal adoptions from Brazil in the 1970s and 1980s, it was previously known. This was followed by the order from Minister Sander Dekker (Legal Protection) to investigate the case further. Adoptions from Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Indonesia and Colombia were also scrutinized.

Dekker did not want to respond on Friday, after the recommendations from the report were leaked. "It is really important that the committee is given the opportunity to present the report with all due care, to show exactly what it contains." The minister found it inappropriate to respond to "such a sensitive topic" on Friday. Prime Minister Mark Rutte also said on Friday that he did not think it wise to respond to the issue.

.

Minister Dekker: international adoption immediately suspended after damning report

The adoption of children from abroad will be suspended immediately. Minister Sander Dekker (Legal Protection) announced this on Monday, in response to a damning report on international adoption in the Netherlands. This also raises the question of whether foreign adoption should be continued in the future.

New applications for adoption from abroad will not be processed for the time being. Parents who have already received permission to bring a child to the Netherlands are allowed to complete the procedure after an additional test.

According to Dekker, the Dutch government has failed to act for years by looking away from abuses during adoptions and not intervening. "It is painful to find that the government has not done what could be expected of it," he said.

According to the minister, for a long time the idea prevailed that parents with adoption were doing 'good'. He called this a well-intentioned but also a somewhat naive sentiment. 'It does offer an explanation for the actions of the government, but no justification.' Dekker apologized on behalf of the government.

Serious wrongs

Dilani Butink raised adoption abuses: 'years have been looked away'

Following a damning report , the adoption of children from abroad has been suspended . Amsterdam's Dilani Butink (29) took the Dutch state to court last year for 'shoddy' around her adoption and is pleasantly surprised by the decision.

“There were some tears when the report's conclusion came out ,” says Butink. “It feels like a kind of emotional rollercoaster that suddenly explodes. In a positive way."

Butink discovered, during a trip to her native Sri Lanka in 2015, that her adoption papers were incorrect . As a result, she will probably never find her biological parents again. The court in The Hague ruled last year that the Dutch state is not liable for this , because the fraudulent practices surrounding Butink's adoption were time-barred. The court also found it impossible to determine whether there had been illegal adoption. “I found, and still think, that an easy legal solution. They looked away again, ”says Butink.

The latter happened for years, according to a committee headed by former top civil servant Tjibbe Joustra. The committee noted in its conclusions yesterday that there were already signs of adoption abuses as far back as the 1960s. Butink was born thirty years later. “Looking away, I had low expectations of the research. I was positively surprised to learn that the report was so critical. ”

Biological mother

Threshold removed for lawsuits after 'shocking' report on adoption abuses

Joy, that was the first reaction of the adopted Dilani Butink when she heard that new adoptions from abroad are being temporarily halted . This was decided in response to a damning research report on the Dutch adoption culture and the role of the government. "I am very happy with the report from the committee and the temporary halt. This just confirms what we have been fighting for all this time, that it has not been in vain."

Dilani Butink was adopted from Sri Lanka in 1992 by Dutch parents. She filed a lawsuit in connection with her adoption procedure, in which, according to her lawyer, serious mistakes were made. Last year, the judge ruled that the case was time-barred , so the court would not deal with the substance of the case. An appeal is still pending.

Butink thinks it must sound crazy to respond happily to such a damning report, but these conclusions make her feel familiar in her grief. "We actually knew what went wrong, but it's nice that it is now being confirmed. And I was shocked to see that things are still not going well."

Mirjam and Doriet also went wrong with their adoption from Indonesia. They later turned out not to be sisters and recently told about this:

31:39