Home  

Beat Jans wants to ban adoptions abroad – Parliament puts a stop to his move

Until 1999, thousands of children came to Switzerland to be adopted by parents, sometimes under dubious circumstances. Nevertheless, the Federal Council's adoption ban is likely to fail – including because of two people directly affected.


Shortly :

  • Thousands of children came to Switzerland through illegal practices between 1970 and 1999.
  • The Legal Affairs Committee of the National Council rejects the adoption ban proposed by the Federal Council by a majority.
  • Two directly affected National Council members are actively campaigning against the ban.

It could have been a rewarding deal for the asylum-plagued Justice Minister Beat Jans. Everyone agrees: The suffering of children adopted from abroad under questionable circumstances must not be repeated. According to the latest findings, between 1970 and 1999, several thousand children from abroad were brought to Switzerland for adoption through child trafficking, with forged documents, missing information about their origins, or through other illegal practices.

 

No ban on international adoptions

No ban on international adoptions

Submitted by:

Committee for Legal Affairs National Council

Reporting:

Gianini Simone

Commission votes against ban on international adoptions

  • Adoptions of children from abroad should continue to be permitted in the future.
  • The responsible National Council committee opposes a ban planned by the Federal Council.
  • Instead, she wants to improve controls on international adoptions.

The National Council's Legal Affairs Committee (RK-N) passed a corresponding motion by 19 votes to 6, according to parliamentary services. The National Council will then decide on the matter.

The majority of the commission wants the Federal Council to "immediately" revisit its fundamental decision from the beginning of the year and, instead of banning international adoptions, increase oversight and transparency. This is intended to reduce the risk of abuse. The argument against a ban is that it would stigmatize adopted persons and their families, according to the statement from the RK-N.

Federal Council looks abroad

At the end of January, the Federal Council announced its intention to ban the adoption of children from abroad. The Federal Department of Justice and Police (FDJP) was tasked with preparing a corresponding consultation draft by the end of 2026 at the latest. A group of experts concluded that abuses could not be ruled out. Such abuses must no longer occur, said Justice Minister Beat Jans. A ban is the best way to protect all those affected, especially children.

Fiom: Response to the De Winter Commission's Investigation

The Commission for the Investigation of Domestic Relinquishment and Adoption today presented its report 'Damage through Shame' to State Secretary Teun Struycken. This report describes the period 1956-1984 of domestic relinquishment and adoption in the Netherlands and its impact on all parties involved. 

The research report stirs up many emotions and memories for all those who had to give up their child, for children who were given up and for families who were involved. The report touches on very personal and painful experiences that have left deep scars for many and have irreversible, lifelong consequences. 

We will carefully study the committee's research report and also critically examine our own role. We want to learn from the past and be of significance to everyone who has had to deal with adoption.  

Does the report evoke something in you that you would like to discuss with us? Please feel free to contact us. We will be happy to make time for you. Send an email to reactie@fiom.nl and let us know which form of contact is most convenient for you.  

AASW Historical Forced Adoption Practices Apology | AASW

18 June 2025

The Australian Association of Social Workers (AASW) unreservedly apologises for the historical forced adoption practices that separated mothers from their babies, and children from their families.

We acknowledge the profound trauma endured by women whose babies were forcibly taken and adopted out, recognising the deep and lasting emotional scars of these unjust practices. We sincerely apologise for the harm caused, honouring their strength and resilience while committing to truth, healing, and remembrance.

Through listening to the stories of people with lived experience we understand and recognise, the profound and continuing harm of these actions, including the deep loss, trauma, disempowerment, and grief experienced by mothers, children, fathers, grandparents, adoptive parents and siblings, families and their descendants.

The AASW recognises that these practices represented serious breaches of human rights and resulted in the loss of family connections, identity and history. We also acknowledge the vital responsibility of the social work profession to uphold and protect human rights in all areas of practice. This means maintaining ethical awareness, fostering critical reflection and challenging practices and systems that risk causing harm.

"A ban on international adoptions does not do justice to my story," says EPP National Councillor Nik Gugger.

Nik Gugger: «Verbot von Auslandadoptionen wird meiner G... https://www.nzz.ch/schweiz/ein-verbot-von-auslandadoptio...

1 of 21 19.06.25, 05:43

Nik Gugger: «Verbot von Auslandadoptionen wird meiner G... https://www.nzz.ch/schweiz/ein-verbot-von-auslandadoptio...

2 of 21 19.06.25, 05:43

Der Zug kurvt durchs grüne Gürbetal, von Bern nach Uetendorf, wo Nik Gugger,
55 Jahre alt, Nationalrat der EVP, aufgewachsen ist. «Siehe da, ich habe immer
Glück», sagt er, als sich die Wolken verziehen.

Trafficking of children: who became millionaires

11/30/2017 | 22:05

(Google Translation)

Trafficking of children: who became millionaires

An organization was detected to remove children from the country under dictatorship.

The millionaire business after the trafficking of children is one of the most unknown chapters in the history of Chile in dictatorship.

Madras High Court P.K. Subramani vs Paster Mani And Anr. on 4 April, 1984

Madras High Court

P.K. Subramani vs Paster Mani And Anr. on 4 April, 1984

Equivalent citations: AIR1986MAD181, AIR 1986 MADRAS 181, (1985) 17 LAWYER 36, 1985 LAWYER 17 36, (1985) 98 MADLW 339, (1985) 1 MADLJ208, (1985) 2 HINDULR 457, (1985) WRITLR 134

Author: S. Natarajan

Bench: S. Natarajan

El Salvador Children Demand the Right to Know Their Origins

After separation during the Civil War

After a DNA test confirmed the family connection, New York resident Sarah Kanfer traveled to El Salvador in November 2024 to reunite with her mother, Eusebia Portillo. The reunion is one of several cases in which children were separated from their parents during the Salvadoran civil war and fraudulently given up for adoption to families abroad. Image: Probúsqueda Association.

By Edgardo Ayala (IPS)

HAVANA TIMES – The children who were snatched from their birth families in the middle of El Salvador’s Civil War are now adults. A group of them are now struggling to adapt to a bittersweet process that still moves them: the joy of having found their families again, but also the sadness of knowing half their lives went by, decades of uncertainty, without being together.