Tjibbe Joustra ziet ‘veel goede wil’ in verbeterplan adoptie, maar ‘invulling zal doorslaggevend zijn’

Ruim een jaar nadat de commissie-Joustra een vernietigend beeld schetste van de interlandelijke adoptie, presenteerde minister Franc Weerwind vorige week verbeterplannen. Voormalig topambtenaar Tjibbe Joustra is nog niet overtuigd. ‘De invulling zal doorslaggevend zijn.’

Haro Kraak19 april 2022, 20:01

Tjibbe Joustra Beeld Kiki Groot

Tjibbe Joustra

The Dutch adoption system has exploded. Earlier this year, the hard-hitting report by the Joustra Committee revealed that the Dutch government had known about abuses in adoptions since the 1960s – from child trafficking to child theft. An acute stop to intercountry adoption followed. A group of adoptive parents, and parties such as the Interlandelijke Adoptees Foundation, oppose the adoption ban and find the report too one-sided: after all, many adoptees in the Netherlands are doing very well, aren't they?

In De Balie, program maker and adoptee Parwin Mirrahimy talks with adoptees and experts: how should the Dutch adoption system proceed?

A pressing task that awaits the new cabinet is to adopt a definitive position on intercountry adoption. Is this possible again in the future? And if so, under what conditions? This evening we are anticipating this by talking to a number of adoptees from different parts of the world. We talk to them about their journey and about their experiences with the Dutch adoption policy. Together with experts, they discuss the pros and cons of the current adoption system.

Adoption brings positive change in many lives. But adoption in its current form too often leads to abuses. What needs to change in the adoption system in the future? And what should we keep?

speakers

East Bogotá, March 2021. The cotton swab should be rubbed deep into the oral cavity against both sides. The Colombian half-sister of Stockholm-based Marta Persson, Hilda Grisales Blandon, takes a deep breath. Trying to swallow the nervousness away.

Ten more seconds. Clear.

Laura Mora puts the stick in a small plastic bag and marks it with her name and social security number. She works for the Dutch organization Plan Angel, which brings together adopted and Colombian families.

The sample must be sent to the Netherlands for analysis. Hilda Grisales Blandon hopes that at least one of her three missing siblings left their DNA in the same registry.

At the end of last year The family contacted Marta. She was adopted to Sweden, but Hermalina Grisales Blandon never gave her written consent.

The lawyer who went too far for the clients

Who : Henriëtte Nakad

Issue : improper practice

Where : Council of Discipline Amsterdam

Folkert Jensma

Managing board

Ellen Giepmans Managing Director

Ellen Giepmans

Managing Director

Mirte Grauss

New Delhi: Ahead of next month’s proposed India-European Union summit in Portugal, European Parliament’s foreign affairs committee has called for both sides to work closely but also expressed concern over the “deteriorating human rights situation in India”.

On April 13, the foreign affairs committee of the European Parliament adopted a report which has a set of recommendations on strengthening the bilateral relationship. The report, adopted with 61 votes in favour and six votes against, will be made public after the European Parliament approves it. Prime Minister Narendra Modi is scheduled to travel to Portugal to attend the India-EU summit on May 8.

According to a press release, the report calls on the EU and India to work together to “promote a shared vision of a rules-based world order in multilateral settings, reinforcing international security, fostering connectivity, fighting climate change and enhancing global economic stability”.

Quoting the committee’s rapporteur, Finnish member of European Parliament(MEP) Alviina Alametsä, the press release stated that India and EU “as the world’s largest democracies have all the possibilities to build a better planet”.

“To fulfil our potential, we need to be more ambitious in our cooperation on preventing climate crises, promoting human rights, building connectivity, sustainable trade and defending a multilateral international order,” she said.

The Constitutional Court has ruled that a trust created by a donor for the benefit of his children and their descendants unfairly discriminated against children adopted by one of his daughters as it did not include them.

Louis John Druiff executed a deed of trust as well as a will “for the benefit of his children and their descendants”.

The deed of trust said any income should be for his four children and their children.

At the time of execution of the deed‚ Druiff had four children‚ three of whom already had children of their own.

One of his daughters‚ Dulcie Helena Harper‚ was married but did not have any children. She later adopted two children.

Mrs Mohini Raghunath

Founder & Secretary

Mrs. Mohini Raghunath, founder and secretary of CWD has had a long and distinguished career in the field of child welfare in India. Her scholarship, vision and commitment to the cause of the ‘disadvantaged child’ is the stuff of legends.

Since the 1970s, key policy initiatives, and path-breaking legislation ideas in the field of child welfare in India, especially adoption and sponsorship have been realized under her signature.

A Delhi School of Social Work graduate (class of 1952), Mrs. Mohini Raghunath started her career at the Maharashtra Government-run Beggar’s Home in Mumbai. In 1976, she joined the Indian Council of Social Welfare (ICSW) as advisor. There, under the guidance of Simone Tata, she authored trend-setting guidelines for inter-country adoption.

They don't cheer. But that adoptions from abroad have been stopped is the only right decision, say Kim, Sophie, Niranka and Kumar. They still have doubts about who they really are. "For years I had a picture on my nightstand of an unknown woman who is not my real mother."

I should be grateful?

Kumar (36): ,, I find some things incomprehensible. Then I hear people say that it is only a problem for a small number of people. And then I think: there are so many Sri Lankan children who have problems because of the adoption. The same people say: we must stop boats with refugees, but bring children from distant lands, that must continue?

“I had to look for my family for 32 years, but I found them. In the end I never met my mother. She passed away in 2010. That is a hard blow. I would have loved to take care of her. “I experienced a lot of racism in my youth, in Zevenaar. On the football field, but also during job interviews.

“There are so many things that you start to doubt. When I was 16, I heard that my date of birth was a completely different one. I suddenly had a different day for my birthday.

A woman who spent almost five years battling to adopt a boy in Uganda said it was "surreal" to now be living in the UK.

Emilie Larter, 29, from Worcestershire, was volunteering for a children's charity in 2014 when she took care of baby Adam, whose mother had died.

She raised thousands of pounds to adopt him, and the pair have been back in the UK since January.

Adam has now started school and is making friends, she said.

Emilie Larter