Home  

Guvernul roman nu si-a respectat promisiunea privind copiii institutionalizati (The Telegraph

Guvernul roman nu si-a respectat promisiunea privind copiii institutionalizati (The Telegraph)
15.11.2010
In 1990, oroarea orfelinatelor din Romania a fost dezvaluita lumii intregi. De aceea se pune intrebarea de ce, dupa milioanele de fonduri ale UE care au fost trimise in aceasta tara pentru a eradica astfel de institutii, inca mii de tineri vulnerabili raman ''incarcerati'' in ele?, se intreaba reportera ziarului The Telegraph, intr-un amplu reportaj din Romania, publicat in editia de luni.
Nu se intampla des sa vezi o bucatica de iad, dar o versiune a acesteia exista la Bistrita, in nordul Romaniei. Acolo se afla un loc care ar fi impropriu pentru animale, pentru a nu mai vorbi de oameni, dar este singura casa cunoscuta pentru 35 de copii institutionalizati, cu varste cuprinse intre cateva saptamani pana la maturitate. Toti au un anumit grad de handicap fizic sau mintal.
Cladirea are o camera mica, unde 10 asa-numiti 'copii' - printre care si un copil palid de cinci ani si unul malnutrit si orb de sapte ani - dorm si isi petrec aici fiecare ora de veghe. Era ora pranzului cand reportera britanica i-a vizitat iar copiilor cu ochii goi li s-a dat fie o sticla, fie piure de cartofi in lapte apos de catre ingrijitoarele mai varstnice.
Jurnalista britanica a intrebat-o pe Anne Marie, directoarea orfelinatului, unde dormea baiatul de sapte ani, avand in vedere ca incaperea avea doar patuturi. 'In patul din colt', a aratat ea, ridicand din umeri. 'Nu se poate intinde, dar este tot ce avem.'
In varsta de patruzeci de ani, parea sa conduca locul cu o automultumire ce iti taia respiratia si cu putine semne ca ar fi legata de copiii aflati in grija ei. Cel mai tulburator dintre toate era linistea ingrijoratoare. Bebelusii, ale caror tipete raman intotdeauna fara raspuns, au devenit repede tacuti. Pe masura ce cresc, se leagana inainte si inapoi, iar mai tarziu se ranesc singuri si devin foarte agresivi.
'Tot ce intelege acest copil este: 'Stai aici, acum!'', a spus Anne Marie, inainte de a arata unele placi de faianta din baie pe care le-ar fi distrus. ''Mi-a inghetat sangele in vine cand ea a continuat'', scrie jurnalista britanica. 'Nu am medicamente suficient de puternice pentru a-l tine linistit, asa ca am incercat sa-l mut intr-o casa cu copii mai mari'. Lui Florin nu i se da nimic de facut si nu poate vorbi cu nimeni.
Intr-o alta camera, la un etaj superior, erau aproximativ 10 forme chircite in paturile lor: a fost greu pentru reportera sa le spuna varsta, dar Anne Marie a afirmat ca ea variaza de la noua la 26 de ani. Era ora doua, intr-o zi insorita de toamna, dar ei zaceau inerti sub paturi murdare, unii legati de pat cu o banda murdara. Nu existau scaune cu rotile sau un lift, niciunul dintre ei nu fusese vreodata afara, iar mirosul de urina si fecale era coplesitor.
Cum poate un astfel de loc sa mai existe inca la peste 20 de ani de cand a fost expusa lumii oroarea orfelinatelor si institutiilor din Romania?, se intreaba jurnalista. Se presupune ca ar fi trebuit sa fie inchise cu mult timp in urma. Stefan Darabus, director de tara al organizatiei de caritate Hope and Homes for Children (HHC), care a insotit-o pe reportera in vizita de luna trecuta, a fost tot atat de socat si furios ca ea.
HHC a fost infiintata in 1994 de colonelul Mark Cook, fost comandant al contingentului britanic al ONU in Croatia si de sotia sa Caroline, cu scopul de a scoate copiii din ingrijirea institutionala si a-i incredinta vietii de familie. Stefan si colegii sai actioneaza in felul lor in intreaga tara pentru inchiderea acestor locuri de nedescris, dar este un proces lent, nu in ultimul rand pentru ca unde sa plasezi astfel de copii parasiti si mutilati?
Este o tragedie de proportii de nedescris pentru atat de multi incat, in timpul regimului de teroare de 25 de ani al lui Nicolae Ceausescu, parintii afectati de saracie erau incurajati sa-si lase copiii in grija statului. El a vrut sa creasca populatia, cu scopul de a crea o 'Armata a Cetatenilor'. Contraceptia si avortul au fost interzise, iar femeilor li s-a spus ca a avea o familie mare era o datorie patriotica. Rezultatul a fost ca parintii au avut mai multi copii decat isi puteau permite sa hraneasca. Nu a existat o alternativa reala decat sa plaseze acesti copii nedoriti intr-o institutie.
Atunci cand Romania a inceput negocierile de aderare la UE, la inceputul anilor '90, o cerinta-cheie a fost ca aceste institutii sa fie inchise, iar guvernul roman a convenit sa faca acest lucru.
In 2000, reportera britanica a vizitat Romania pentru a raporta asupra progreselor facute. A fost o vizita traumatica si profund tulburatoare unde a vazut multi copii neglijati, subnutriti, cu boli cum ar fi tuberculoza, hepatita si Sida.
''Am crezut in asigurarile guvernului roman ca viza ca toate casele pentru copii institutionalizati sa fie inchise in termen de 10 ani. Atunci cand Romania a aderat la UE in 2007, am presupus ca a fost aproape de atingerea acestui obiectiv. Ceea ce am gasit luna trecuta a fost faptul ca, desi s-au facut unele progrese - 450 institutii cu circa 160.000 de copii au fost inchise - Romania nu si-a eradicat inca trecutul rusinos. Institutia de la Bistrita este una dintre cele 256 in care zac inca peste de 10.800 copii'', noteaza critic semnatara articolului.
Realitatea dura este ca a inchide o institutie costa echivalentul a 100.000 de lire streline. UE a contribuit cu o suma in jur de 36 de milioane de lire pana in prezent. Astazi, aproximativ 20% din cost provine de la consiliile locale si 80% de la HHC. Este, de asemenea, un proces indelungat, necesitand minimum 18 luni pentru a gasi case potrivite pentru fiecare copil, cu acces la asistenti sociali instruiti si psihologi pentru a-i ajuta sa se indrepte spre un fel de viata normala.
In plus, se fac eforturi pentru a gasi familia care a dat nastere fiecarui copil pentru a vedea daca doreste sa se implice; unele familii inca nu stiu daca copiii lor au fost luati sau daca mai sunt inca in viata. Aproximativ 35% din copii revin la casa parinteasca permanent. Copiii pot fi de asemenea plasati in 'case de tip familial mici' - aflate la jumatatea drumului intre o institutie si asistentii maternali. Altii, cu sprijin, sunt luati de unele familii. Adoptarea este un proces judiciar complex, dar exista in prezent aproximativ 14.500 de asistenti maternali care ingrijesc aproximativ 26.500 copii. Adoptiile internationale au fost oprite in 2007, de teama ca ar fi condus la trafic si abuzuri (intre 600 si 700 de copii si-au gasit o casa in Marea Britanie).
Exista, de asemenea, sarcina dificila de reeducare a romanilor in materie de ingrijire a copiilor si valoare a vietii de familie. In ceea ce priveste schimbarea atitudinii populatiei de 21 milioane, HHC a ajutat pana acum 1.500 de familii 'cu risc', avand intre doi si sapte copii, sa ramana impreuna, oferind sprijin si asistenta pentru ingrijirea copiilor. Este un pas important, dar mic, si o sarcina imposibila pentru orice organizatie de caritate care actioneaza pe cont propriu.
''Guvernului roman ar trebui sa-i fie rusine ca nu face din ingrijirea copiilor, asa cum a promis, o prioritate'', a concluzionat in aceeasi nota critica jurnalista britanica.
Dupa o stire Agerpres

Russian Official Doesn't Rule Out Possible US Adoption Freeze

Russian Official Doesn't Rule Out Possible US Adoption Freeze

FRIDAY, 12 NOVEMBER 2010 13:59

WRITTEN BY RIA NOVOSTI

Russian Children's Ombudsman Pavel Astakhov may push for a freeze on adoptions of Russian children by U.S. citizens if Russia and the United States fail to seal an adoption agreement by early 2011.

"In case problems arise by the beginning of the next year and we are unable to push this agreement through and do not reach the stage where we just have to sign it, then I am ready to raise the serious issue of a juridical freeze on U.S. adoptions," Astakhov said on Friday.

Astakhov to demand moratorium on adoptions by US citizens

Astakhov to demand moratorium on adoptions by US citizens
 
Nov 12, 2010 15:21 Moscow Time
Pavel Astakhov. Photo:RIA Novosti
Print
Email
Add to blog
The Children Rights Commissioner for the Russian President Pavel Astakhov says he is prepared to raise the issue of imposing a moratorium on adoptions of Russian children by US parents.
This will prove the case if the signing of an intergovernmental agreement to that end is delayed.
Russia raised the issue of signing this kind of agreement with the United States following a spate of tragic incidents involving adopted kids.
According to the Russian Prosecutor’s Office, prior to 2006, when Russia toughened the adoption rules, US foster parents had killed 12 adopted Russian children.

Jugendhilfe: Reiche Eltern sollen zahlen

Jugendhilfe: Reiche Eltern sollen zahlen
025.11.10||
Fürstenfeldbruck - Landrat Thomas Karmasin fordert, dass das Jugendhilfegesetz geändert wird. Reiche Eltern sollen selbst zahlen. Das untermauert er jetzt mit einem konkreten Beispiel.
Der Fall: Betuchte Eltern aus dem Landkreis adoptieren gegen ausdrücklichen Rat Kinder aus der Ukraine. Aus guten Gründen habe das Ehepaar in Deutschland keine Genehmigung zur Adoption bekommen, sagte Karmasin. Die Eltern kommen mit den zwei Kindern nicht zu Recht. Es kommt zu Misshandlungen.
Die Kinder kommen ins Heim. Das Ganze entwickelt sich, so Karmasin wörtlich, zu einer „menschlichen Tragödie“.
Und zu einem finanziellen Desaster. 700 000 Euro verschlingt der Fall. Dass der Kreis diese Summe zahlen musste, sei ein „ bodenloser Skandal“, sagte Karmasin.
Zumal den Eltern wirklich geraten worden sei, auf die Adoption zu verzichten. „In diesem Fall halte ich es für denkbar, dass die Eltern ihr Einfamilienhaus zur Verfügung stellen.“
Karmasin schilderte das Beispiel nicht nur im Kreisausschuss. Auch in seiner Rede beim Wirtschaftsempfang hatte er es in ähnlicher Form vorgetragen.
Damals erinnerte er daran, dass der Landkreis gerade einmal die Hälfe des erwähnten Betrags als Zuschüsse an die Musikschulen im Kreis überweise. Der Hinweis, dass beides nicht miteinander vergleichbar sei, stimme nur bedingt. „Wir werden in einigen Wochen bei den Haushaltsberatungen über das eine reden, weil wir nach derzeitiger Rechtslage das andere bezahlen müssen.“

Call for inquiry into Magdalene laundries

The Irish Times - Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Call for inquiry into Magdalene laundries

PATSY McGARRY, Religious Affairs Correspondent

THE IRISH Human Rights Commission (IHRC) has called on the Government to set up a statutory inquiry into treatment of women and girls in Magdalene laundries. It also said financial redress should be available to survivors.

The Government said it had “asked the Attorney General in consultation with relevant departments to consider the IHRC’s report”, but expressed regret “that relevant departments were not offered an opportunity by the IHRC to contribute to the commission’s considerations of this matter to facilitate a fully balanced evaluation of all the facts”.

The Government was “conscious that the Magdalene laundries were run by a number of religious congregations” and noted the IHRC would not conduct an inquiry itself.

Possibly anticipating this question, commission chief executive Éamonn Mac Aodha said at the press conference that an inquiry by it could not deliver the apology and redress sought from the State for the women and girls involved. “We do not have those type of powers,” he said.

As to the costs of such an inquiry, commission president Dr Maurice Manning said issues at stake were so fundamental that an inquiry should go ahead. “There is no reason why it should be lengthy, as a great deal of the evidence has been gathered,” he said.

Fianna Fáil TDs Tom Kitt and Michael Kennedy, Labour TD Kathleen Lynch and Independent TD Maureen O’Sullivan attended the IHRC event.

Speaking during the adjournment debate in the Dáil last night, Mr Kitt said he strongly supported the commission’s stance. Survivors “should receive an apology from the State” and a distinct redress scheme for them “should be established”, he said. “The survivors of the Bethany Home should be treated in the same way.” He asked the Conference of the Religious in Ireland (Cori) and the four religious congregations that operated the laundries to meet the Justice For Magdalenes group “to deal with the issues of records, compensation and other related matters”.

Last June, the Justice for Magdalenes group asked the commission to inquire into treatment of women and girls in Magdalene laundries. The commission agreed to do so, and to examine the human rights issues arising.

The principal findings by the commission’s inquiry, on which it based its recommendations yesterday, were that “for those girls and women who entered Magdalene laundries following a court process, there was clear State involvement in their entry to the laundries”.

It found questions arose “as to whether the State’s obligations to guard against arbitrary detention were met in the absence of information on whether and how girls and women under court processes resided in and left the laundries”. It found the State may have breached the 1930 Forced Labour Convention and Article 4 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Of the Magdalene laundry in Drumcondra, Dublin, it said: “The burial, exhumation and cremation of known and unknown women from a Magdalene laundry in 1993 at High Park raises serious questions for the State in the absence of detailed legislation governing the area.”

Olive Braiden, of the commission, said: “We are dealing with a small and vulnerable group of women who the Government admitted as far back as 2001 were victims of abuse.” Dr Manning said: “The State cannot abdicate from its responsibilities in relation to the treatment of women and girls in the Magdalene laundries.”

Prof James Smith of the Justice for Magdalenes group said “the Government must move beyond its ‘deny ’til they die’ policy.”

Maeve O’Rourke, co-author of the group’s submission to the commission, said the State “must convince the church to acknowledge its part in this scandal, and to open up its records”. It should also call on the church “to pay its share of compensation to survivors”.

Veterans' forgotten story: How thousands of Korean orphans were saved

Originally published November 10, 2010 at 10:32 PM | Page modified November 11, 2010 at 3:35 PM
Comments (33)     E-mailE-mail article      PrintPrint view      ShareShare
Veterans' forgotten story: How thousands of Korean orphans were saved
A story of how countless U.S. soldiers helped save the lives of thousands of orphaned Korean children during the Korean War, nearly 60 years ago.
Seattle Times staff reporter
PREV 1 of 4 NEXT 
Retired professor George Drake is interviewed by a Korean documentary film crew at the site of the Korean memorial in Bellingham.
Enlarge this photo
STEVE RINGMAN / THE SEATTLE TIMES
Retired professor George Drake is interviewed by a Korean documentary film crew at the site of the Korean memorial in Bellingham.
Korean orphans, pictured living on the streets, were helped by U.S. servicemen during the Korea War.
Enlarge this photo
PHOTOGRAPHER UNKNOWN
Korean orphans, pictured living on the streets, were helped by U.S. servicemen during the Korea War.
War vet George Drake
 
War vet George Drake
 Bob Rue, a war orphan
 
Bob Rue, a war orphan
Related
Veterans Day events
Olympia: 10:30 a.m., annual Veterans Day Ceremony in the Capitol Rotunda. For more information, 360-888-8211.
Museum of Flight: 1 p.m., annual ceremony at 9404 E. Marginal Way S., Seattle. Retired U.S. Air Force Col. Chuck DeBellevue, recognized for his six aerial-combat victories during the Vietnam War, will speak. All veterans and current military personnel admitted to the museum free.
Seattle Veterans Museum: Open from 10 a.m.-5 p.m., at Second Avenue between Union and University streets. For more information, 425-949-8821or www.seattleveteransmuseum.org.
University of Washington: 10:30 a.m., annual ceremony at the Medal of Honor Memorial, Memorial Way (northwest of Kane Hall). Remarks by Eric Godfrey, vice provost of UW Student Life. A reception will follow in Kane Hall, and the ROTC will hold an open house at noon in Clark Hall.
Korean War Children's Memorial website
Retired professor George Drake has created a website honoring the U.S. soldiers who helped rescue orphaned Korean children during the Korean War. It includes more than a thousand stories and a thousand photos about the orphanages. More information at www.koreanchildren.org
advertising
 
BELLINGHAM —
First of all, this story is not about George Drake.
Yes, the colorful 80-year-old retired sociology professor tells a great tale, one in which he plays an important role — even if he insists it's a minor one.
Rather, this is the story of how countless American soldiers helped save the lives of thousands of orphaned Korean children during the Korean War, nearly 60 years ago.
It is a forgotten story, Drake says, because that war itself was so brutal and horrific that soldiers did not want to talk about it when they came back home. And because stories of selflessness and humanity in a war zone decades ago are trumped in the headlines by atrocities on today's battlefields.
So, on this Veterans Day, we turn to Drake to learn how he and countless other U.S. soldiers, working independently of one another, helped build and assist Korean orphanages across that country during the war.
By one count, U.S. troops aided 100,000 children who were set adrift after their families were split by warfare, their parents killed by bombs, rampant disease or hunger. The war, fought between 1950 and 1953, was the first significant armed conflict of the Cold War.
It took Drake 12 years of research, and trips to Washington, D.C., and Tokyo. In the end, he has quantified the breadth and scope of help U.S. soldiers gave to roughly 400 Korean orphanages.
"I'm a sociologist, I'm interested in collective behavior," Drake said. "I put together 1,800 of these stories. It's a story that's never been told."
Documentary
One day in October this year, a South Korean film crew arrived at Drake's Bellingham house at the tip of Lake Whatcom, next to Big Rock Garden Park.
Korean-American producer Jessica Oh, with CJ Media in Seoul, was the fourth South Korean journalist to trek to Bellingham to interview Drake. In South Korea, the story of the Korean orphans has been spreading.
Oh's documentary, expected to air on TV in South Korea in December, will tell the story of the war from a Korean-American woman's perspective. Oh was intrigued to learn about the children orphaned by the war.
"What amazed me was ... that George Drake had such an unbelievable attachment with these kids, which he still does," Oh said.
With her was Bob Rue, a retired Bellevue dental technician and Korean War orphan. Rue lived in the orphanage where Drake was a volunteer.
"I love these people — they took care of me," said Rue, who later changed his Korean name to an American one and immigrated to the United States. "I had no clothes. No food. Looked like a wild doggy."
Rue pulled from his wallet two well-worn photos of himself at age 10 — dressed in surplus GI clothing and a captain's hat, he poses with several grinning U.S. soldiers.
"How sweet, how warm their hearts," he said.
Drake does not know if he met Rue in the camp. As many times as he insists the story is not about him, he has had trouble redirecting the gratitude of Koreans whose lives were saved by somebody in a soldier's uniform. He has become for many orphans the embodiment of all compassionate American soldiers — a kind of GI everyman.
"I've met six kids who said I saved their lives," Drake said. "Sometimes, I think they're mistaken. But that's all right. They need closure also. They need somebody to say thank you to."
Starved
George Drake was 22 when he enlisted in the Army and was sent to Korea in 1952. He'd studied Chinese in college and did well on an Army aptitude test, so he was given a job in intelligence, in the 326th Communication Reconnaissance Company in the city of Uijeongbu.
Not long after he arrived, Drake and other soldiers volunteered at a nearby orphanage, where they were warmly greeted by a dozen children. "They were starved for affection," he said.
But also, literally, they were starving — malnourished, diseased, barely clothed and dirty. Drake had never seen such poverty, or such desperation.
The soldiers wrote letters home, describing the conditions and asking for help from churches, Rotary clubs and other organizations. Americans began shipping clothes and supplies to the orphanages in such quantity that at one point, with the packages stacking up on the wharf in San Francisco, the Army had to lease a freighter to bring it all over, Drake said.
William Asbury directed field operations in Korea during the war for the Christian Children's Fund. He estimates that about 100,000 Korean orphans were aided by soldiers' efforts.
"I refer to them as an army of compassion, and it really was exactly that," said Asbury, 86, who later became editor of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer and now lives in Olympia, where he is retired.
Asbury, a veteran of World War II, thinks American aid to orphans in Korea was unlike humanitarian efforts in World War II because the troops were dug in during long stretches. That gave the GIs time to get to know the orphans.
There's a darker side to this story, too, Asbury notes: Thousands of children were born to Korean mothers and American military fathers during the conflict. Some of these children ended up in orphanages, too.
Aiding the orphans helped the soldiers assuage their own conflicted feelings about the brutality of the war, Drake said. More than two million people were killed, including countless civilians, and 37,000 U.S. soldiers.
"The GIs had to convince themselves they were not killers," he said. "They needed the kids to reconfirm to themselves that they were caring human beings."
Back to U.S.
After the fighting stopped, Drake went back to school, getting his bachelor's and master's degrees at the University of California, Berkeley. He married and starting teaching at Western Washington University. He was the founding director of WWU's China Teaching Program, director of the school's Center for East Asian Studies and a member of the Bellingham City Council from 1974 to 77.
In 1998, shortly before the 50th anniversary of the Korean War, Drake, now retired, began to think about the orphans' story. He had a hunch that the soldiers' humanitarian aid had been more widespread than anyone knew, but that the story had been lost to history.
He began digging into microfilm at WWU. He went on research trips: to the U.S. National Archives in College Park, Md., and the archives of the Pacific Stars and Stripes in Tokyo. Packing a portable scanner, he scanned about a thousand photos and newspaper stories about the war orphans. And he began to collect stories from GIs and former orphans.
He developed a Web page, and in 2005, helped create an exhibit of photos that was displayed in the MGM Grand in Las Vegas called "GIs and the Kids — A Love Story."
Drake phoned Asbury out of the blue one day. The two men became good friends. Asbury says Drake has been relentless, and selfless, in his work to tell the story about the GIs and the orphans.
Drake has been to South Korea six times since the fighting stopped, and "I'm somewhat in awe of the amount of interest in Korea," he said. But he's also wary of the attention that's been showered on him.
During a visit to Gwangju, South Korea, he was made an honorary citizen of the city. But he tore up his prepared speech at the ceremony and begged people to realize that he was just one of thousands of servicemen who aided Korean orphans.
And when Jessica Oh and her camera crew visited Drake in Bellingham, he kept reminding her that he was just a bit player, just the historian.
"I am not the story," he said to Oh. "Remember that."
Katherine Long: 206-464-2219

Deported from Chicago, she waits for Barack Obama

You are here: HOME > MUMBAI > Report

Deported from Chicago, she waits for Barack Obama
Published: Saturday, Nov 6, 2010, 2:22 IST
By Mayura Janwalkar | Place: Mumbai | Agency: DNA

Jennifer Haynes, 28, abruptly deported from Chicago in 2008, is eagerly waiting for US president Barack Obama’s visit to Mumbai in the hope that her letter will reach him and she may be able to go home to her husband and children.

In her letter to the president on November 2, Haynes has stated, “Until last year I believed that I was a US citizen. Now I realise that I was a victim of child-trafficking, sexual abuse and exploitation.” Her letter was submitted to the US consulate in Mumbai.

Haynes was adopted by an American couple in 1989 at the age of seven. However, her experience in 50 different foster homes was traumatic, she has stated.

DNA had first reported Haynes’ case when she moved the Bombay high court seeking action against her adoption centre, which did not complete the necessary formalities at the time of her adoption and after being booked for a drug felony she was deported to India, 20 years after she had seen it last.

Her husband Justin and children Kadafi, 7, and Kanassa, 6, live in Chicago. Haynes, however, without a passport of either countries, lives in India with no family, no source of income and no documents to avail a job.

“Never did I think I was not an American citizen until I was arrested for a minor drug charge and sent immediately for deportation. Your country which had promised me so much hope, instead treated me like an object to be discarded like damaged goods,” Haynes had said in her letter.

“Can you please help me?” Haynes has asked president Obama. She has also said, “Now I am an American without a country; a lost child who was sent away from my home, my family and my children.”

Sangeeta Punekar of the Advait Foundation and Anjali Pawar of Sakhee, the NGOs supporting Haynes’ case, have also urged Obama to let her go back to the US.









Ukraine: U.S. Department of State Adoption Notice – November 3, 2010 (suspension)

Ukraine: U.S. Department of State Adoption Notice – November 3, 2010

From the U.S. Department of State:

Ukraine

Adoption Notice

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF STATE
Bureau of Consular Affairs
Office of Children’s Issues


November 3, 2010

 

The Ukrainian legislature is in the process of voting on a bill that would suspend all intercountry adoptions from countries without bilateral agreements with Ukraine, including adoptions from the United States.  The bill passed a first reading and vote, but must still pass a second reading and be signed into law by the president.  The second reading could take place in the next few weeks.  If the bill passes the second reading, it may be signed into law as early as the end of 2010.  The draft bill appears to include suspension of all adoptions in progress. The Department will post updates as information becomes available.

South African woman waiting to adopt from Preetmandir asks activist to drop her demand for inquiry

South African woman waiting to adopt from Preetmandir asks activist to drop her demand for inquiry

The president of an NGO called Sakhee on Wednesday allegedly received a threat call from a South African woman waiting to adopt a baby from city-based Preetmandir. The caller asked the social activist, Anjali Pawar, to discontinue her efforts to ensure an investigation into whether the children waiting for adoption at Preetmandir were indeed destitute.

Unpleasant experience: Anjali Pawar, president of NGO Sakhee, says she got the call on Wednesday evening

Pawar said the woman who called from South Africa introduced herself as Linda Ganess and repeatedly made abusive remarks over the phone. The woman was upset over the fact that Pawar had demanded an inquiry into the destitute status of each and every one of the 17 children waiting for adoption at Preetmandir, which has been under a cloud for some months over its adoption system.

Saying the children at Preetmandir were suffering because of the delay in adoption, Ganess allegedly demanded the activist withdraw the objection she had filed with organisations and apex bodies working in the field of adoption.

The Bombay High Court had directed the Central Adoption Resource Agency (CARA) to consider 18 cases of international adoption recommended by Preetmandir.

Bulgaria Vows to Phase Out Orphanages, Promote Adoption and Foster Care

November 05, 2010

Bulgaria Vows to Phase Out Orphanages, Promote Adoption and Foster Care

From Novinite.com:

 

Bulgaria’s Health Ministry has announced it is starting to gradually close orphanages for children below three years of age.

According to the ministry, all the children from the orphanages have to be returned to their biological parents or given for foster care in the next 15 years.

The first nine orphanages for children below three years of age will be closed in the next five years. The financing, which is expected to be more than BGN 26 M, will be provided under the operation programs “Regional Development” and “Human Resources Development.”

The process of shutting down such institutions is part of the “Vision for deinstitutionalization of children in Bulgaria.”

The number of institutions for children below three years of age is 32. They have accommodated 2,334 children and only 0,7% of them are orphans.

According to the Health Ministry, the most common reasons why parent abandon their children are social-economic problems, lack of skills or capacity for raising children, health problems, family violence, unwanted or premature birth.

Analyses, however, show that appropriate policy could allow children to be returned to their families or could prevent their abandonment in the first place.

However, the opportunities for every child depend on the specific circumstances.

Data from the ministry shows that a total of 1,260 children from the 32 orphanages are not disabled and at least half of them could be returned to their biological families. The rest could be adopted or accommodated with foster parents.

At present, there are more than 475 foster families in Bulgaria, which have accommodated more than 417 children. Last year, 800 children were adopted. The rest 1,074 children that are left in the institutions have disabilities or chronic illnesses.

Without question, this initiative is a promising start to child welfare reform in Bulgaria, but the proof will be in the execution. I've posted before about the appalling conditions for vulnerable children in Bulgaria. Three years ago, documentary filmmaker Kate Blewett took her cameras inside a Bulgarian orphanage for the disabled. The resulting film, Bulgaria's Abandoned Children, sparked an international outcry that echoed the dramatic response to Blewett's best known work,  The Dying Rooms, the award-winning expose about shocking conditions inside China's neglectful institutions for children. Ultimately, the Bulgarian government was shamed into improving conditions inside its orphanages for disabled and mentally challenged children. It's likely that international pressure is prompting this latest development as well. Though this new plan promises support to help keep original families of healthy children intact, the plan doesn't extend to support for families of disabled children, so clearly, the marginalization of these children continues.

Bulgaria's new plan favors foster care, and while quality foster care offers children a better start than orphanage life, high quality foster care is rare. As Suffolk Law Professor Sara Dillon has pointed out on her blog:

In the US, statistics indicate that 70-80% of prison inmates are former foster children….The problem of uneven quality, rotating placements, vulnerability to further abuse and neglect–these are endemic to foster care systems….

It is foster care that should be used sparingly, selectively and only as an alternative to institutions….There is simply no comparison between adoption, domestic or international, and foster care….

I can only hope that the Bulgarian government will fully commit itself to promoting family support and reunification, then adoption, and then, quality foster care. Maybe officials there should check out this video for the Be the One child rights campaign here in the US, which features the adult perspectives of former foster children.