Home  

South Africa: Dad's adoption anguish

Dad's adoption anguish

 

    Karyn Maughan

    September 10 2008 at 07:21AM

 
 

 

Jose Williams refused to agree to his baby daughter's adoption - and "walked into hell".

 

Now he has been forced to watch his first child spend the first five months of her life in a state-subsidised "place of safety", while the Pretoria Children's Court decides who will take care of her.

 

As the October 1 date of his daughter's "child in need of care" hearing looms, Williams, 26, is praying that she will come home to him, his mother Heloise Renate Sequeira and his two sisters.

 

But he also faces the prospect of her being placed in foster care.

 

"I have spent the last five months praying and crying," he told The Star, "All I want is to bring my baby home to her family, where she belongs."

 

 

 

 

Williams has spent thousands of rands on lawyers' fees, drug tests and a social worker's assessment of his suitability as a parent. His family have prepared and decorated a bedroom for the baby, which is filled with clothes that are now much too small for her.

 

Williams has hired a lawyer to force the adoption agency to let him visit his little girl.

 

He claims he has been allowed to visit her only six times, but the agency denies this.

 

Williams says he learnt that his baby's mother wanted to have her adopted only when she contacted him to ask if he would attend "counselling" to reconcile their tumultuous 11-month relationship.

 

"When I arrived at the 'counselling' venue and saw the name 'Abba Adoptions', my heart fell… but I was absolutely clear that I was not going to allow my child to be adopted," he said.

 

Under the new Children's Act, an unmarried father can acquire full parental responsibilities and rights if he consents to be identified as the child's father or has contributed to the child's upbringing or maintenance. All of these conditions apply to Williams.

 

Despite the fact that Williams had refused to agree to his daughter's adoption, Abba removed the baby to a place of safety after her birth.

 

Abba manager Katinka Pieterse claims this was at the behest of the Children's Court.

 

Williams and his mother learnt of his daughter's birth by SMS. They immediately drove to the Pretoria Children's Court, where Sequeira says she discovered the April 16 court roll and found a reference to her granddaughter's hearing as an inter-country adoption.

 

Armed with a March 6 affidavit from his baby's mother, in which she seemingly relinquished all her rights to her child to him, a desperately worried Williams arrived at the Children's Court on April 16.

 

But, he claims, his reception was less than friendly.

 

"No one wanted to read anything I had brought with me.

 

"I asked the magistrate handling the case what I could do and what my options were, and she told me to get a lawyer if I needed legal advice."

 

The magistrate in question, child commissioner Sarie Snyman, on Tuesday declined to comment on any aspect related to Williams' claims or his battle for custody. She however stressed that the case was "never an adoption".

 

"I cannot discuss this with you… it's in the law," she said.

 

Pieterse on Tuesday stressed that the Children's Court would "make a decision about what is in the best interests of his daughter".

 

"This is not an ideal world… This man must understand that there is a legal system in place and he must accept that there is a legal route to be followed."

 

The baby's mother could not be reached for comment.

3 Nepali kids set to land in US

3 Nepali kids set to land in US

Kantipur Report

KATHMANDU, Sept 9 - After a gap of one and half years three Nepali children are all set to land in the U.S with their new adoptive parents. This was made possible for three orphaned girls —Anita Himali, Anisha Sai and Santi Sai — after the government approved their documents related to inter-country adoption.

The adoptive mothers are Bonnie Lee Donohue of Wisconsin, Michelle Kyla Blanchard-Roma of Louisiana and Dr. Teryl Rae Elam of Alaska.

Donohue, who is a general manager in the food service sector, has been matched with three-year-old Himali, Blanchard-Roma, who is a reputed Louisiana-based attorney, has been matched with two-year-old Anisha, and reputed Alaska-based physician, Elam has been matched with nearly one-year-old Santi.

Chinese children's homes pay for children

Chinese children's homes pay money to finders who drop children off at homes. This is apparent from an investigation by the Ministry of Justice following a Network report on adoption from China. According to China, these are 'symbolic amounts'.

Netwerk managed to obtain the contents of a draft letter on this subject from Justice Minister Hirsch Ballin to the House of Representatives. In it he discusses the fuss that arose in March about adoptions from China following a report by Netwerk. That report revealed that children's homes in Hunan province pay for children brought in. Many -also Dutch- adopted children come from this province. The ministry then launched its own investigation.

In the draft report, the ministry calls the Chinese adoption system 'vulnerable'. "Possible new irregularities are reported with some regularity," the report said. The Chinese adoption agency has admitted to the ministry that "symbolic amounts" are paid to finders who deliver children to children's homes. Last March's Network broadcast showed that finders were paid semi-annual salaries.

According to the Hague Adoption Convention, which both the Netherlands and China have signed, it is prohibited to pay finders of children. "Not a dollar, not a cent," the Hague Permanent Bureau on the Adoption Convention told Netwerk in March. The letter to the House of Representatives shows that the Ministry of Justice has doubts about whether this ban is being observed in the provinces. "Many children's homes are located in poor regions where small amounts can be of great significance," the report said. That can encourage child trafficking.

Emeritus professor Rene Hoksbergen speaks in a reaction of 'a critical report'. He has doubts about new adoptions from China. Hoksbergen: 'It is extremely difficult for the Netherlands to continue in the same way after this report. But it is up to the adoption organizations to make a decision about this'.

Red tapism delays relief for parents

Red tapism delays relief for parents

September 1, 2008

K Praveen Kumar

TNN

CHENNAI: Three years after the controversy over illegal adoptions carried out by Malaysian Social Services (MSS), hit the news stands, the story has made it to the headlines again following a recent report by a foreign publication.

The Great Indian adoption racket across four continents

The Great Indian adoption racket across four continents

Lakshmy Ramanathan, TNN, Sep 1, 2008, 05.30am IST

Article

Comments

CHENNAI: Seven thirty on a chill February evening: residents of the Pulianthope slum off the Pulianthope high road in North Chennai had gathered outside their shanties to cook their last meal for the day.

'God decided before he was born that I am his mother'

Sunday, August 31, 2008'God decided before he was born that I am his mother'

Mohammed Adam The Ottawa Citizen Sunday, August 31, 2008

The Nairobi High Court Building is a grand monument to justice, but when Peggy Taillon stepped into Courtroom 33 one fateful February morning, she wondered what kind of justice awaited her.

Painful truth about adopted children

Painful truth about adopted children

August 26, 2008

Siobhain Ryan and Sean Parnell

WHEN Julia Rollings first heard that the orphanage from which she had adopted her son and daughter was embroiled in a child-trafficking scandal, she was faced with a life-changing choice.

She could do nothing, safe in the knowledge that her children, Akil and Sabila, had been declared free for adoption by Indian courts, were Australian citizens and were in a place they called home.

Premier can't recall stolen kid cases

Premier can't recall stolen kid cases
August 25, 2008
QUEENSLAND Premier Anna Bligh says she was not aware of adoptions of stolen Indian children during her time as child safety minister.
Indian authorities and the Federal Government are investigating allegations that more than a dozen children kidnapped from Indian slums have ended up being adopted in Australia.

Qld Govt investigates adoption after kidnapping claim

Qld Govt investigates adoption after kidnapping claim
Posted 2 hours 39 minutes ago
Updated 2 hours 21 minutes ago
Anna Bligh says it is too early to be speculating.
Anna Bligh says it is too early to be speculating. (ABC TV: file photo)

E-Mail exchange including Lynelle and Julia Fwd: FW: Kids 'kidnapped for Aussie adoption'

From: Lynelle Beveridge [mailto:icasn@bigpond.net.au]

Sent: Montag, 25. August 2008 05:14

To: 'Julia Rollings'; 'Ricky Brisson - AFC'; 'Marilyn Nagesh'; 'Gary Banks'; 'Helen Edwards'; 'John Ford'; 'Eun Bryan'; treasurer@aacasa.org.au; 'Aileen Berry'; 'Julie Rankin'; 'Mark Byrne'; 'Mark Stewart'; 'Mahoney Sonya'; 'Marianne Saliba'

Subject: RE: Kids 'kidnapped for Aussie adoption'

I believe we as a Peak Group (and as individual organisations) should be pushing for the Australian Govt to conduct an investigation / full inquiry into these Indian adoptions and ensure that Australian procedures are tightened to prevent adoptions from organisations that have a history of, or any questionable behaviour of child trafficking / stolen children. If the Netherlands can do this, surely the Australian Government can also take some responsible action?