Home  

U.S. hopes to finalize talks on child adoption with Russia this week

U.S. hopes to finalize talks on child adoption with Russia this week

01 Dec 2010  

The United States hopes to finalize an agreement on child adoptions with Russia this week and sign it in the nearest future, a spokesman for the U.S. Department of State said.“Officials have met four times in both Washington and Moscow to negotiate this agreement that provides greater safeguards for children and families in the adoption process between the two countries, and we will anticipate that these talks tomorrow will be – with officials on both sides – reviewing the final text so that there can be a signing in the near future,” Assistant Secretary Philip Crowley told.
Russia and the United States are holding the fifth round of talks on drafting a child adoption agreement in Washington on December 1-3. The U.S. official also added that the United States hopes to conclude the process during this round of talks with Russia “but the formal agreement will not be signed.”

Source: RIA Novosti

Your Story is Our Story: The Adoption and Baptism of My Son

 
"At the deepest level the story of any one of us," Frederick Buechner wrote in his book Yellow Leaves, "is the story of all of us."
Standing on the beach surrounded by 75 friends and family last month, a few minutes before my son was baptized in the Pacific, Buechner's words rolled through my mind like the waves crashing gently on the shore a few yards from my bare feet.
How we all got to that place in the sand on the southern coast of California is an epic story, the best one I know. It is a story of grace and redemption, of God's providence and tenderness, of friendship and the bonds of community that even death cannot sever. It is our story, all of us.
Three years ago, in a humble enclave of mud-and-wattle huts by the side of a dusty African road, I met, by accident (if you believe in such things) the sick little boy who would become my son. At the time, I had no idea how intimately intertwined our lives, and our stories, would become.
When I met Vasco, he was 8 years old, an AIDS orphan who had lived alone on the streets of Malawi for a time. He had a hole in his heart and didn't have long to live. In April 2009, he came to the United States to have life-saving surgery, and today, he is in perfect health. In June, Vasco became my son, legally and forever, when the High Court of Malawi approved our adoption.
Vasco's story is remarkable. I've lived it with him and it still gives me goose bumps. I tell it again and again because it is not just his story or my family's story, but our story -- all of us broken and beautiful human beings. We are all adopted sons and daughters of God, each of us a chosen member of a global and eternal family, stitched together by grace.
My son's baptism was not only a public affirmation of his relationship with God and a commemoration of the day a 30-year-old Nazarene was baptized in the Jordan River by his cousin John 2,000 years ago, it also was a symbol of his adoption into the communion of the saints, living and dead -- the cloud of great witnesses who stood with him on the beach and who watched his big splash from afar (and yet close by, in the spirit.)
Vasco was baptized in the same waters where the ashes of the uncle he never met, "Mr. Mark," were spread. Mark's parents, sister, wife and daughter witnessed Vasco's baptism from the beach with us, while Mark watched from the other side.
2010-10-27-vandbubba.jpg
Before our pastor walked Vasco down to the water to dunk him, Vasco's godfather, whom we call "Uncle Bubba," shared a few words of wisdom with his new godson.
"Vasco, God has given you a wonderful story to tell. Your story of what God did for you is your dad's story, it's your mom's story. And now it's my story, too," he said. "Vasco, this is all of our story. As people we are living lives with hearts that need to be fixed, in places that are unsafe. Jesus comes and gives us new hearts and puts us in a new family and gives us a new name, his name. God has given you a wonderful story and I want you to always tell your story."
Bubba and I have been friends for more than 20 years. We met as freshmen in college and have been inseparable ever since. Our friendship is an unlikely one. He is a farmer from Mississippi, a son of the south and a diehard conservative Five Point Presbyterian. I am a member of the liberal media, a Connecticut Yankee and spiritual traveler. Still, he and I go together like carrots and peas (I'm the carrots).
The only way I can explain our enduring friendship is that God created it and sustains it. The go-between God who makes connections between people that we'd never be able to make on our own, saw these two polar opposite 18 year olds and thought, "Yeah. That's a great match. Watch this!" With that, God knit our stories into one beautiful tapestry of soul friendship.
My friendship with Bubba is perhaps as whimsically unlikely as meeting my son by the side of the road in Malawi was. Both are stories of profound grace as unbelievable as they are true, stories that their author -- God alone -- has now woven magnificently into one.

Adoptie prikbord - geduld dan lukt het wel (Indonesie)

Re: Adoptie Indonesie

Gepost door: marian ()
Datum: 07 oktober 2009 10:17

Heb begrepen dat het zowieso niet mogelijk is om een kindje te adopteren wat je van tevoren al kent. 
Ik heb ook vele kinderen in Kenia gezien die ik zo zou willen adopteren. Bij navraag bleek dat dit niet mag ook niet als je de familie bijv. zelf kent. Indonesie is ook niet mogelijk via deelbemiddeling? 

Marian

Re: Adoptie Indonesie

Gepost door: Jasmijn ()
Datum: 29 november 2010 17:11

Als je gewoon belt naar een adoptie bureau.. 
en geduld neemt, lukt het wel. 
Ik ken iemand die ook zo een kindje uit Indonesia heeft kunnen krijgen.

Embettled adoption agency defends its role


Embattled adoption agency defends its role
25 October 2009 By Susan Mitchell 

It has not been a good year for Sharon O’Driscoll. As chief executive of Helping Hands, which facilitates overseas adoptions from Vietnam, she has been at the centre of a media storm surrounding the issue of how adoptions from the country are arranged.

Last May, it emerged that a bilateral agreement covering adoptions between Vietnam and Ireland had not been renewed.

Without it, no legal adoptions can be processed in Vietnam. Minister for Children Barry Andrews refused to explain why the agreement had not been renewed, and was accused of leaving hundreds of prospective adoptive parents in limbo.

Then an unfavourable draft United Nations report which painted an unflattering picture of Helping Hands was leaked to the press. It emerged that the Adoption Board was also seeking clarification of the fees charged by Helping Hands for its services.

O’Driscoll has, in the main, shunned the media, but over the past week, appears to have reversed that strategy. She is now keen to shed some light on a number of the concerns raised, in particular media coverage of the draft UN report.

This described the information Helping Hands provides to the public as ‘‘at least somewhat misleading and consequently disturbing in its implications’’.

Parents who have adopted from Vietnam in recent years paid $11,100 (€7,400) to Helping Hands. Of that, $9,000 was paid as ‘‘humanitarian aid’’ to regional authorities in Vietnam.

O’Driscoll acknowledged that Helping Hands had not always lodged that humanitarian aid to identifiable bank accounts.

About €3 million has been paid out in total and sizeable sums - she was unable to disclose the precise amounts - were paid over in cash. Helping Hands did not receive audited accounts from the Vietnamese.

‘‘It’s just the way things are done," O’Driscoll said.

She added that Helping Hands had repeatedly expressed concerns about the lack of accountability for money paid out in Vietnam in humanitarian aid, and had raised the issue a number of times with the Adopt ion Board. ‘‘We made recommendations about this to the Adoption Board as far back as 2006.

We said greater accountability was needed and we continued to make that point," she said.

That said, she does not believe the money is going astray. ‘‘I go out there every eight weeks and I see the progress that is being made on the ground with the money," she said.

O’Driscoll said criticism of Helping Hands in the draft report from the UN International Social Service (ISS) solely pertained to a recent $1,000 increase in the fee levied for humanitarian aid. The report’s authors claimed Helping Hands had not clarified this increase.

‘‘The first we knew about this was when we read it in the papers," said O’Driscoll. ‘‘We had never even been contacted by them about it. We wrote to them and they sent us a set of questions, which we subsequently responded to."

A recent letter from the UN body confirmed there had been a mix-up over the initial questionnaire, which was sent to the wrong address, and that the recent response ‘‘clarified very well the main questions’’ it had. It said this would be reflected in its final report.

O’Driscoll said she had also responded to similar queries from the Adoption Board.

She feels aggrieved at the leaking of elements of the ISS report and details of correspondence between Helping Hands and the Adoption Board.

‘‘The draft ISS report was leaked inappropriately and was done to cause trouble, in my view. Stuff from the Adoption Board was mysteriously leaked. I’m assuming my most recent response will be leaked too," she said. ‘‘But it is very hurtful to the applicants and the children involved, many of whom are of school age. I have raised it with the department and the Adoption Board. What is the agenda?"

The amount paid in humanitarian aid by Irish parents is agreed in informal round table discussions with Vietnamese authorities, O’Driscoll said, adding that she believed the amount should be decided at government level.

The bilateral agreement that was agreed between the Irish and Vietnamese governments, and which expired in May, contained a clause stipulating that humanitarian aid be paid to the donor country. It failed to specify the amount, whereas bilateral agreements that the Vietnamese have with other countries specify the precise amount.

O’Driscoll said the amount charged to parents in Ireland was similar to the amount paid by parents in other countries who were also adopting from Vietnam. ‘‘There is a misconception about this," she said.

Other sources rejected that statement. In France, for example, parents pay half that amount for the processing of the application and the humanitarian fee combined.

O’Driscoll said all money paid to Helping Hands by adoptive parents was placed in a holding account. ‘‘We receive none of that money," she said.

‘‘The $9,000 is paid directly to regional authorities and the remaining $2,100 is used to cover medical checks, the processing of all documentation, translation and notarisation, and transport costs. We make the payments on the parents’ behalf. We don’t charge for the service. We are funded entirely b y the HSE."

Helping Hands has received funding of €1.6 million from the Health Service Executive since 2006.

O’Driscoll said there was ‘‘simply no chance’’ that an Irish parent would end up with a child who was put up for adoption in the circumstances that were outlined in a report in the Daily Mail last weekend.

The report read: ‘‘In a dingy shack, young women wait to give birth. Soon, for a few dollars, they will hand their newborn to desperate Irish couples."

O’Driscoll said Helping Hands existed to protect people from such a scenario. Such an adoption would never be registered in Ireland in the first place, according to O’Driscoll, as the adoption had to be referred through the Vietnamese Central Authority.

Under the previous bilateral agreement, every adoption had to be conducted through a mediation agency licensed by both central authorities, O’Driscoll said.

‘‘They have a very stringent process, as do we. I have always found them very diligent. The paperwork is examined and re-examined.

‘‘We also got them to introduce a database to ensure there is a clear trail of all the documentation. It gives added protection," she said.

‘‘We have no worries or concerns over the eligibility of any of the children we have facilitated adoptions for."

Barry Andrews has said he will consider the ISS report - which is expected to be published in mid-November - before deciding whether to renew the bilateral agreement with Vietnam.

The question beckons: if the minister is as concerned as he purports to be, why is his office trying to process 20 applications that had already been received by the Vietnamese before the bilateral agreement lapsed?

O’Driscoll was reluctant to be drawn on this. She evidently doesn’t want to offend the man who may hold the key to the survival of her organisation. ‘‘I don’t know," she said.

The Helping Hands saga has overshadowed other concerns that have been raised about the inter-country adoption process in Ireland.

They include the bureaucratic minefield people face when being assessed for adoption and the failure to ratify the Hague convention (aimed at improving the inter-country adoption process). Ireland committed to ratifying it in 1993 and we will be the last country in the European Union to do so.

O’Driscoll said Helping Hands had been inundated with calls from concerned adoptive parents and prospective adoptive parents in recent months.

‘‘It is desperate for them. Many are up to are eight years in the system," she said.

‘‘I have seen the draft ISS report and there is nothing in that report we did not know before. I think the big thing that is being forgotten is that the Vietnamese commissioned the ISS and the Unicef report.

There were a huge number of domestic adoptions in Vietnam last year. Nobody is reporting that. There were 12,000 domestic adoptions and 3,000 intercountry adoptions - which is unlike any other donor country.

They are improving their processes all the time and they want to improve their processes. That is being lost." 

Vietnam adoption procedures treat children as 'commodities'

Vietnam adoption procedures treat children as 'commodities'
October 31, 2010 8:00 PM EDT
The disclosure emerged in internal US State Department documents which reveal a network of people, from adoption agency representatives, orphanage directors, hospital administrators right through to government officials and local police, were profiting by paying for children, as well as coercing and defrauding natural parents into giving up their children for adoption. 

The documents, from 2007 and 2008, show in some cases, children were simply stolen from their families to sell them to unsuspecting American couples. Throughout hundreds of pages of material, US officials – including the country's ambassador to Vietnam, Michael W Michalak, and Assistant Secretary of State Maura Harty – express their growing concerns over adoption practices in Vietnam. 

Following these concerns, which included evidence of "baby farming" and "baby selling", the USA eventually decided not to renew its bilateral agreement with Vietnam in September 2008. 

Ireland followed suit in May of 2009. 

It is understood the Irish Embassy in Vietnam had also expressed "serious concerns" as to adoption practices in the country. 

The US documents also show US adoption agencies' contracts with provincial authorities for "humanitarian donations" was putting pressure on the adoption system to meet the growing need to provide children for adoption. Ireland has adopted more than 600 children from the south-east Asian country between 2002 and 2008. 

The new Adoption Act, which comes into force today, will finally complete Ireland's ratification of the Hague Convention on inter-country adoption. 

Irish people approved to adopt from abroad will only be able to adopt children from a Hague Convention country or from a country with which Ireland has a bilateral agreement. However, anybody who has a declaration of suitability to adopt before the November 1 will be allowed to proceed with a non-Hague country.

Veterans' forgotten story: How thousands of Korean orphans were saved

Originally published November 10, 2010 at 10:32 PM | Page modified November 11, 2010 at 3:35 PM
Comments (33)     E-mailE-mail article      PrintPrint view      ShareShare
Veterans' forgotten story: How thousands of Korean orphans were saved
A story of how countless U.S. soldiers helped save the lives of thousands of orphaned Korean children during the Korean War, nearly 60 years ago.
Seattle Times staff reporter
PREV 1 of 4 NEXT 
Retired professor George Drake is interviewed by a Korean documentary film crew at the site of the Korean memorial in Bellingham.
Enlarge this photo
STEVE RINGMAN / THE SEATTLE TIMES
Retired professor George Drake is interviewed by a Korean documentary film crew at the site of the Korean memorial in Bellingham.
Korean orphans, pictured living on the streets, were helped by U.S. servicemen during the Korea War.
Enlarge this photo
PHOTOGRAPHER UNKNOWN
Korean orphans, pictured living on the streets, were helped by U.S. servicemen during the Korea War.
War vet George Drake
 
War vet George Drake
 Bob Rue, a war orphan
 
Bob Rue, a war orphan
Related
Veterans Day events
Olympia: 10:30 a.m., annual Veterans Day Ceremony in the Capitol Rotunda. For more information, 360-888-8211.
Museum of Flight: 1 p.m., annual ceremony at 9404 E. Marginal Way S., Seattle. Retired U.S. Air Force Col. Chuck DeBellevue, recognized for his six aerial-combat victories during the Vietnam War, will speak. All veterans and current military personnel admitted to the museum free.
Seattle Veterans Museum: Open from 10 a.m.-5 p.m., at Second Avenue between Union and University streets. For more information, 425-949-8821or www.seattleveteransmuseum.org.
University of Washington: 10:30 a.m., annual ceremony at the Medal of Honor Memorial, Memorial Way (northwest of Kane Hall). Remarks by Eric Godfrey, vice provost of UW Student Life. A reception will follow in Kane Hall, and the ROTC will hold an open house at noon in Clark Hall.
Korean War Children's Memorial website
Retired professor George Drake has created a website honoring the U.S. soldiers who helped rescue orphaned Korean children during the Korean War. It includes more than a thousand stories and a thousand photos about the orphanages. More information at www.koreanchildren.org
advertising
 
BELLINGHAM —
First of all, this story is not about George Drake.
Yes, the colorful 80-year-old retired sociology professor tells a great tale, one in which he plays an important role — even if he insists it's a minor one.
Rather, this is the story of how countless American soldiers helped save the lives of thousands of orphaned Korean children during the Korean War, nearly 60 years ago.
It is a forgotten story, Drake says, because that war itself was so brutal and horrific that soldiers did not want to talk about it when they came back home. And because stories of selflessness and humanity in a war zone decades ago are trumped in the headlines by atrocities on today's battlefields.
So, on this Veterans Day, we turn to Drake to learn how he and countless other U.S. soldiers, working independently of one another, helped build and assist Korean orphanages across that country during the war.
By one count, U.S. troops aided 100,000 children who were set adrift after their families were split by warfare, their parents killed by bombs, rampant disease or hunger. The war, fought between 1950 and 1953, was the first significant armed conflict of the Cold War.
It took Drake 12 years of research, and trips to Washington, D.C., and Tokyo. In the end, he has quantified the breadth and scope of help U.S. soldiers gave to roughly 400 Korean orphanages.
"I'm a sociologist, I'm interested in collective behavior," Drake said. "I put together 1,800 of these stories. It's a story that's never been told."
Documentary
One day in October this year, a South Korean film crew arrived at Drake's Bellingham house at the tip of Lake Whatcom, next to Big Rock Garden Park.
Korean-American producer Jessica Oh, with CJ Media in Seoul, was the fourth South Korean journalist to trek to Bellingham to interview Drake. In South Korea, the story of the Korean orphans has been spreading.
Oh's documentary, expected to air on TV in South Korea in December, will tell the story of the war from a Korean-American woman's perspective. Oh was intrigued to learn about the children orphaned by the war.
"What amazed me was ... that George Drake had such an unbelievable attachment with these kids, which he still does," Oh said.
With her was Bob Rue, a retired Bellevue dental technician and Korean War orphan. Rue lived in the orphanage where Drake was a volunteer.
"I love these people — they took care of me," said Rue, who later changed his Korean name to an American one and immigrated to the United States. "I had no clothes. No food. Looked like a wild doggy."
Rue pulled from his wallet two well-worn photos of himself at age 10 — dressed in surplus GI clothing and a captain's hat, he poses with several grinning U.S. soldiers.
"How sweet, how warm their hearts," he said.
Drake does not know if he met Rue in the camp. As many times as he insists the story is not about him, he has had trouble redirecting the gratitude of Koreans whose lives were saved by somebody in a soldier's uniform. He has become for many orphans the embodiment of all compassionate American soldiers — a kind of GI everyman.
"I've met six kids who said I saved their lives," Drake said. "Sometimes, I think they're mistaken. But that's all right. They need closure also. They need somebody to say thank you to."
Starved
George Drake was 22 when he enlisted in the Army and was sent to Korea in 1952. He'd studied Chinese in college and did well on an Army aptitude test, so he was given a job in intelligence, in the 326th Communication Reconnaissance Company in the city of Uijeongbu.
Not long after he arrived, Drake and other soldiers volunteered at a nearby orphanage, where they were warmly greeted by a dozen children. "They were starved for affection," he said.
But also, literally, they were starving — malnourished, diseased, barely clothed and dirty. Drake had never seen such poverty, or such desperation.
The soldiers wrote letters home, describing the conditions and asking for help from churches, Rotary clubs and other organizations. Americans began shipping clothes and supplies to the orphanages in such quantity that at one point, with the packages stacking up on the wharf in San Francisco, the Army had to lease a freighter to bring it all over, Drake said.
William Asbury directed field operations in Korea during the war for the Christian Children's Fund. He estimates that about 100,000 Korean orphans were aided by soldiers' efforts.
"I refer to them as an army of compassion, and it really was exactly that," said Asbury, 86, who later became editor of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer and now lives in Olympia, where he is retired.
Asbury, a veteran of World War II, thinks American aid to orphans in Korea was unlike humanitarian efforts in World War II because the troops were dug in during long stretches. That gave the GIs time to get to know the orphans.
There's a darker side to this story, too, Asbury notes: Thousands of children were born to Korean mothers and American military fathers during the conflict. Some of these children ended up in orphanages, too.
Aiding the orphans helped the soldiers assuage their own conflicted feelings about the brutality of the war, Drake said. More than two million people were killed, including countless civilians, and 37,000 U.S. soldiers.
"The GIs had to convince themselves they were not killers," he said. "They needed the kids to reconfirm to themselves that they were caring human beings."
Back to U.S.
After the fighting stopped, Drake went back to school, getting his bachelor's and master's degrees at the University of California, Berkeley. He married and starting teaching at Western Washington University. He was the founding director of WWU's China Teaching Program, director of the school's Center for East Asian Studies and a member of the Bellingham City Council from 1974 to 77.
In 1998, shortly before the 50th anniversary of the Korean War, Drake, now retired, began to think about the orphans' story. He had a hunch that the soldiers' humanitarian aid had been more widespread than anyone knew, but that the story had been lost to history.
He began digging into microfilm at WWU. He went on research trips: to the U.S. National Archives in College Park, Md., and the archives of the Pacific Stars and Stripes in Tokyo. Packing a portable scanner, he scanned about a thousand photos and newspaper stories about the war orphans. And he began to collect stories from GIs and former orphans.
He developed a Web page, and in 2005, helped create an exhibit of photos that was displayed in the MGM Grand in Las Vegas called "GIs and the Kids — A Love Story."
Drake phoned Asbury out of the blue one day. The two men became good friends. Asbury says Drake has been relentless, and selfless, in his work to tell the story about the GIs and the orphans.
Drake has been to South Korea six times since the fighting stopped, and "I'm somewhat in awe of the amount of interest in Korea," he said. But he's also wary of the attention that's been showered on him.
During a visit to Gwangju, South Korea, he was made an honorary citizen of the city. But he tore up his prepared speech at the ceremony and begged people to realize that he was just one of thousands of servicemen who aided Korean orphans.
And when Jessica Oh and her camera crew visited Drake in Bellingham, he kept reminding her that he was just a bit player, just the historian.
"I am not the story," he said to Oh. "Remember that."
Katherine Long: 206-464-2219

Single Mothers in Morocco Abandoned Thousands of Babies Each Year

Single Mothers in Morocco Abandoned Thousands of Babies Each Year
Anne Look | Dakar 29 November 2010
Abandoned children sleep in an orphanage, Morocco
Photo: © UNICEF Morocco/2010
Abandoned children sleep in an orphanage in Morocco
Share This
Related Articles
Related Links
Thousands of babies are abandoned in Morocco every year because their single mothers are too afraid to face family and friends. Instead of just taking in abandoned children, one nonprofit has begun working with families to help single mothers find ways to keep their babies.
At this center for abandoned children in Marrakech, kids play and sing with caretakers.

The home currently has about 60 children, between four-days and seven-years old. Many of them were born to single mothers who abandoned them at a young age. 

Experts say it is a growing phenomenon in Morocco, where aid agencies estimate that more than 6,000 babies are abandoned at birth each year, roughly one in 50 babies born. 

Having a child outside of marriage carries heavy stigma in the moderate Muslim country. Single mothers find it hard to turn to their friends and family for support, but a German-based group, The League for Child Protection, is seeking to change that. 

The League runs this home for abandoned children in Marrakech and others like it around the country, but it is also working with single mothers and their families to try to prevent children from being abandoned in the first place.

The League's Director, Lamia Chrabi Lazreck, says they are making headway.

Lazrek says they have been doing mediation work with some of the parents of single mothers. He says sometimes they have also been able to mediate with the father of the child. He says they have found work for these women and offered to care for their babies temporarily at the center for three or four months so they may have some time to sort themselves out.

Most of the women who come to the center in Marrakech are below the age of 25, several of them are under 18.

One single mother said she is working with counselors to try to persuade the father of her two-year-old child, Maryam, to officially recognize the baby so she can have the legal status and rights of a legitimate child.

She says she wishes the administrative procedures for her daughter could be sorted out so she can live like any other child and have everything she needs. She says she does not want people pointing fingers at her. Our society, she says, is not very forgiving.

Moroccan law provides protection for single mothers, but entrenched cultural norms mean they still face enormous social barriers. Those who choose to keep their babies can be ostracized by family and friends and find it difficult to support themselves.

Despite important reforms to Morrocco's Family Code in 2004, the law provides little protection to single mothers who can still face criminal prosecution for having had sex outside of marriage.

UNICEF Representative to Morocco Aloys Kamuragiye applauded the intervention and support the League for Child Protection is giving mothers and their families. 

He says it is a very interesting and important experiment the League is leading in Marrakech. He says it should be supported by all Moroccans and replicated throughout the country.
The League runs six other centers in Morocco. Aid agencies say government and societal support for the League's activities is growing, but much remains to be done.
 

Foreign adoptions - History (Romanian adoptions not recognised)

Foreign Adoptions

Published on 27 Jul 10

Background pre 1991

Up to 1991 the number of foreign adoptions involving Irish residents was very small. In addition there was no structural framework in existence in Ireland under which foreign adoptions could be given full legal recognition. The Adoption Act of 1952 which dealt with domestic adoptions only did not cover foreign adoptions.

However during the 1980’s due to the change in social attitude and improvements in the welfare system the number of Irish born children being offered for adoption dwindled to such an extent that the needs of Irish couples seeking to adopt could no longer be satisfied from within the State. Accordingly despite the absence of a structural framework a large number of Irish couples began to look aboard for children that they might adopt. In 1989 Romania allowed foreign adoption and a large number of children were brought to Ireland. There was no official procedure in place for assessing the eligibility and suitability of persons intending to adopt abroad. Consequently Irish couples negotiated the terms of a child’s adoption with the local adoption agency in Romania following which they appeared before a local Court for the purposes of securing approval of the adoption and leave to remove the child from Romania. They then travelled back to Ireland with their child. These adoptions though apparently valid under Romanian law were not recognised under Irish law.

Present Day Situation

In 1991 the Adoption Act was passed to remedy this situation. This provided the necessary Statutory framework for all future foreign adoptions involving couples of Irish domicile or residence. The Act authorised the making of Adoption Orders in respect of foreign adoptions which also included adoptions made before the commencement of the Act provided such adoptions were deemed lawful under the law of the place in which the adoptions were effected or otherwise met certain criteria laid down by the Act.

The Act provided for the establishment of the Adoption Board and maintenance of a register of foreign adoptions. Registration rights were also extended to Irish couples either where domiciled or habitually resident in the country.

Eligibility and Suitability Test

Persons intending to adoption a child must be able to prove that they fall within one of the categories of persons eligible to be adopters and then undergo a rigorous assessment (the House Study Programme) to determine their suitability to be adopters. Such assessments are carried out by the appropriate Health Service Executive area or by a registered Adoptions Society. Eligibility is generally determined by reference of martial status and consanguinity or other relationship based on or arising from marriage. The intended adopters must be over 21 years of age and must be ordinarily resident in this state. Suitability is based on the intending adopters being able to satisfy by means of their assessment the criteria contained within Section 13 of the Adoption Act of 1952.

One very beneficial effect of the procedures is that persons now going abroad to adopt are much better prepared for what lies ahead and the risk of having a disappointing or traumatic experience is substantially reduced.

Document Dossier

Persons who have obtained from the Adoption Board a Declaration of Eligibility and Suitability and who are in a possession of an Immigration Certificate may commence the next stage of preparation which is to satisfy the regulations and procedures of the Authorities of the foreign country where the adoption is to be effected. This can be onerous and time consuming official requirements vary from country to country. Intending adopters are obliged to send a dossier containing a substantial amount of information and documentation. This is a very lengthy list and would require inter alia visits to An Garda Siochana, medical Doctors, birth certificates, marriage certificates, etc.

The proposed adopters are generally required to obtain a Notary Public for the purpose of having the adoption papers notarised.

The timeframe in processing a successful application is lengthy and would be applicants should allow for this when commencing the Adoption process.

If you require any further information please contact David Lavelle or Jennifer Ward.

Adoptions from Vietnam may not be recognised, says board

Monday, September 21, 2009 Adoptions from Vietnam may not be recognised, says board Related » Vietnamese adoptions face scrutiny | 21/09/2009 In this section » Senior Anglo executives borrowed nearly €22m from bank Sam has no need for sat nav as Kerry take scenic route to title CAROL COULTER Legal Affairs Editor THE ADOPTION Board has warned prospective adoptive parents that any planned foreign adoptions from Vietnam have no special status here and may not be recognised under Irish law. The board sent out the notice last week, warning prospective adopters that any application to adopt from Vietnam would be examined to ensure it complied with Irish adoption law, and would be decided on a case-by-case basis. According to a notice from the Minister for Children, Barry Andrews, on the website of the Adoption Board last June, the mediation licence of the Irish adoption agency operating in Vietnam, Helping Hands, has been revoked by the Vietnamese government. This follows the expiry of a bilateral agreement with Vietnam last May. Although talks had been taking place with the Vietnamese government about an interim agreement, such an agreement has been put on hold by Mr Andrews, pending the consideration of two UN reports by his department. In the absence of an agreement, no legal adoptions can be processed in Vietnam. The two UN reports follow the publication of a highly critical US report on adoption in Vietnam in April of last year. Among the abuses it found were instances where children were described as “deserted” when their parents could be found and identified, unexplained pockets of “desertions” in certain areas and payments to the birth parents of “relinquished” children, though these are outlawed by Vietnamese law. The problem it identified was the autonomy of local officials, and the inability of the central authority in Vietnam, the Department of International Adoption (DIA), to police what happens at local level. These concerns are reiterated in the two reports at present under consideration by the Minister. One of them, an unpublished draft report carried out by the UN’s International Social Service (ISS) in co-operation with the Vietnamese authorities, is highly critical of the Helping Hands agency, whose public information it describes as “at least somewhat misleading and consequently disturbing in its implications”. The ISS draws attention specifically to the fact that the fee to the agency for an adoption from Vietnam is $11,100, while the official Vietnamese fees are less than $200. The Helping Hands agency told the ISS that of the $11,100, $2,100 went on administration and $9,000 in “humanitarian aid”. The figure of $11,100 included a recent increase of $1,000. The ISS report comments: “We wonder in what form and by which entity of the Vietnamese authorities Helping Hands had been advised of such an increase, whether any explanation had been given and whether the increase related to ‘fees’ or ‘aid’.” The unpublished draft report added: “We were unfortunately not able to obtain this information within the time-frame of this assessment.” The information may be contained in the final report when it is published. When asked by The Irish Times to comment on the ISS report, the chief executive of Helping Hands, Sharon O’Driscoll, said she had nothing to say, but a spokesman would be in contact later this week. Analysis, page 5 This article appears in the print edition of the Irish Times

s

Adoption fees 'misleading'


August 23, 2009

Adoption fees 'misleading'

 

 

Helping Hands, the agency that arranged all 182 adoptions between Vietnam and Ireland last year, is criticised by a draft Unicef report for a lack of transparency in charging prospective parents $11,100 (€7,757) when the “real fee” is $2,100.

The Cork-based agency, which is funded by the Health Service Executive, is accused of providing a “misleading” breakdown of fees.

The report describes the relationship between western adoption agencies and Vietnamese orphanages as unhealthy. It follows a joint Unicef/Vietnamese analysis which said that the Asian country’s adoption law had a lack of safeguards.

The criticism of Helping Hands is being taken “very seriously” by the Irish government, according to sources. Vietnam accounts for 46% of international adoptions to Ireland but an agreement between the states lapsed in May. Barry Andrews, the minister for children, is under pressure from 200 prospective Irish parents to make a new arrangement.

The report, however, calls on Vietnam to suspend all international adoptions until 2011.

It says adoptions from Vietnam are “demand-driven” and recommends a “total divorce between money given as ‘humanitarian aid’” and inter-country adoption.

“Agencies compete with each other to secure children and tend to expect that children will be ‘indicated’ to them . . . according to the amount of aid provided.”

The report’s authors said Helping Hands’ $11,100 fee includes only $2,100 for administration. The remainder is classed as “humanitarian aid”.

Helping Hands is criticised for not being “upfront” about the breakdown of its fee, which increased from $10,100 last June. The agency attributed the increase to “Vietnamese authorities” in a letter to the Adoption Board, but the report points out that Vietnamese fees are less than $200.

The agency is run by Sharon O’Driscoll, a former member of the Adoption Board. It said it had not seen the report and could not see the context of the criticisms.

The report says: “We wonder . . . whether the increase related to ‘fees’ or to ‘aid’. We feel bound to look on the content of this ‘information letter’ as being at least somewhat misleading and consequently disturbing in its implications.”

Kiernan Gildea, the board’s registrar, said it has established a review group to examine “the regulation and registration” of Helping Hands.