Home  

Adoption a commercial deal in India: Plea in SC

Adoption a commercial deal in India: Plea in SC
 
Krishnadas Rajagopal Tags : Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA), Child adoption process, Padma Shri winner Nomita Chandy, AshrayaPosted: Fri Apr 22 2011, 02:10 hrs New Delhi:
 
Child adoption process in the country came under the Supreme Court’s scrutiny on Thursday with the court demanding an explanation from the Ministry of Women and Child Development and the government’s Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA) on the charge that adoption of babies has become nothing more than a “commercial transaction” involving private placement agencies.
 
A three-judge Bench, led by Chief Justice of India S H Kapadia, issued notices to the government and CARA to explain why adopting parents are made to wait for months, entangled in “reams of red-tape”, and foreign parents find it easier to adopt than their Indian counterparts.
 
The CARA has “failed on every count” to monitor and regulate placement agencies, contends the petition filed by 2011 Padma Shri winner Nomita Chandy’s adoption agency Ashraya.
 
“Total apathy and corruption of the respondents (ministry and CARA) has led to the adoption process being reduced to a farce, and empowering opaque state-run children’s homes and criminal private individuals to play with the lives of adoptable children and adopting parents, very often reducing the solemn process of adoption to a commercial transaction involving little babies,” stated the petition argued by senior advocate K K Venugopal.

Geadopteerde Libanese kinderen slaken noodkreet

  Geadopteerde Libanese kinderen slaken noodkreet

Verslag: Marc Schrikkema  Redactie: Josefin Hoenders 

In 1975 kregen twee Libanese baby's de oerhollandse namen Steven Sonneveld en David-Jan Baan en werden ze ter adoptie afgestaan aan echtparen in Nederland.
De burgeroorlog in Libanon was net begonnen en een stroom van vaak illegale adopties kwam op gang. Duizenden Libanese kinderen werden wereldwijd geadopteerd. Maar liefst 400 Libanese kinderen kwamen in Nederland terecht, veelal door bemiddeling van het domineesechtpaar Ibrahim en Adla Chemayel.


Nu, ruim 35 jaar later, zitten Steven en David-Jan met vele vragen over hun herkomst. Doordat de kinderen bij hun geboorte in het ziekenhuis al Nederlandse namen kregen en de identiteit van de biologische moeders nergens werd vastgelegd is het terugvinden van zelfs maar een de vrouwen vrijwel onmogelijk.
Onlangs richtten Steven en David-Jan de stichting Children of the Cedars op, in de hoop op die manier meer druk op de Libanese overheid te kunnen uitoefenen hen in hun zoektocht bij te staan. Als ook maar een van de 400 moeders gevonden wordt, dan is hun missie geslaagd. EenVandaag volgde Steven en David-Jan bij hun pogingen meer duidelijkheid te krijgen over hun verleden, in de hoop de toekomst vrijer tegemoet te gaan.

‘I was made to give my baby away’

‘I was made to give my baby away’

Seema Shinde tried to commit suicide on Tuesday. She says her in-laws rejected her as she was of lower caste, her husband tricked her into giving baby to adoption centre

 

Nadeem Inamdar
     

 

Posted On Thursday, April 21, 2011 at 01:41:15 AM

 

 

Seema and Prashant at their wedding in Alandi

Around 7.30 pm on Tuesday, when Seema Devidas Shinde stood contemplating the dark waters of the river Pavana over the railing of the M M Vidyamandir bridge near Kalewadi in Chinchwad, there seemed little else to do, except jump. A few minutes ago, her husband Prashant had categorically told her that their marriage was unacceptable to his parents as she belonged to a lower caste. She had already given her four-month-old baby to an adoption centre.

Happily, Seema’s depths of despair didn’t find the river’s rocky bottom, thanks to the timely intervention of an alert bystander. Her rescuer then took her to the Kalewadi police chowky, where yet another ugly episode of the silent battle of the castes was recorded in the station diary.

Sometime in 2009, Seema told police, she met Prashant Kadam at the private educational institute for young children where she was working as a teacher, and Prashant was posted as store keeper. They soon fell in love, and the intimacy developed into a physical relationship. She was seven months pregnant when their marriage took place in Alandi on November 7, 2010. Her baby, a girl, was born on December 26 that year in a Bhosari hospital. 

“When our baby was born, Prashant told me that he would take me home on the condition that I deposited the baby with an adoption centre. I trusted him and gave the baby to Nachiket Balgram in Akurdi. However, Prashant did not keep his promise. 

On Tuesday, I met him at the bridge and told that I will commit suicide. He was unfazed, and said his family would never accept me as their daughter-in-law. I could not bear to take his words, and decided to end my life. What could I do? I had given my baby to the adoption centre for my husband’s sake,” Seema told Pune Mirror after recording her statement with the police.

That evening on the bridge, Seema says she flatly told him to stop playing with her emotions and take her home. Prashant refused, she claimed, saying it was impossible as they belonged to different castes. She added that prior to this, Prashant had refused to take her home on several occasions, citing pressure from his parents. 

“Prashant said I was unwanted in his house since I am from the Mahar community. His parents assaulted and abused me and don’t want me to stay with them,” Seema told Mirror. In her written statement to Kalewadi police, Seema claimed she had gone to meet her in-laws twice, but was assaulted and driven out of the house by Prashant’s mother and sister.

Sachin Phulsundar
Seema Shinde’s statement being recorded in the presence of activists on Wednesday

After avoiding several calls, Prashant finally spoke to Mirror. “I did not place any such condition that the baby should be deposited at the adoption centre. The girl’s parents had demanded Rs 1 lakh for settling the dispute. They have complained against me to police because I did not give them money. I have not uttered casteist comments against her. Right now, I am not in a position to speak as I am hurt by the allegations levelled against me by her family and their supporters,” he said.

Seema was brought to the Kalewadi police chowky on Wednesday afternoon by local Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) activists. The activists demanded that Prashant be booked under the Atrocities Act and arrested. However, police inspector (Crime) Bhagwat Sonawane of Chinchwad PS said the police wanted to try for an amicable end to the dispute, as it was a family matter.

However, her baby is still hers, and she can take succour from that fact. “I can take my child back as officials have kept that option open,” Seema said, a barely perceptible smile on her lips.

?   I did not place any condition that the baby should be deposited at the adoption centre. The girl’s parents had demanded Rs 1 lakh for settling the dispute. I have not uttered casteist 
comments against her

- Prashant Kadam Husband

 ?   My husband Prashant said I was unwanted in his house as I am from the dalit community. His parents assaulted and abused me and don’t want me to stay with them

Divorced in India, reunited in Zedelgem

They were best friends in an orphanage in India. Until they were both adopted and separated from each other. By an unlikely coincidence, Teena (6) and Wine (5) are now reunited in Zedelgem, West Flanders. They live one kilometer apart and go to the same school. "Teena and Wine are like sisters to each other."

The touching reunion happened about three years ago. The two girls saw each other on the playground of their school in Zedelgem. Immediately the recognition was there, and they fell into each other's arms. According to their adoptive parents, there was "a spark of recognition" between Teena Kyndt and Wine Dierick: the feeling that they had known each other from birth. meetingThe coincidence became even greater when their adoptive parents turned out to be friends. They live a kilometer apart in Zedelgem and got to know each other during the long adoption procedure - both couples wanted a child from India through De Vreugdezaaders. Teena (now 6) came to Belgium in September 2007 and went to live with one couple, Wine (5) followed in March 2008 and got a home with the other couple. No one in Belgium had any idea of ??the special bond between the two girls who were best friends at the orphanage in Calcutta. Until that meeting on their school playground. Hilde, Wine's mother: 'Teena is six months older than Wine, and she remembered very well the name of her best friend.' language problem'The children didn't have to get used to each other at all. They just picked up the thread they had lost a year before," says Bart, Teena's dad. The two girls did have a practical problem. Bart: 'Teena already spoke Dutch and Wine only Bengali. But they understood each other without words. You really saw that there was already a strong bond between those two.' Since the unlikely reunion, the two have been like sisters to each other, Teena's mom Conny says. 'Exactly magnets. Other children can play on the playground, but they belong together. They are always very sweet and caring for each other.' princessesWhy Teena is so important to Wine? "Because she's from my country," says the youngest. "Wine comes to sleep with us every now and then," Teena adds. 'We are friends, forever and ever. We also dance together.' That's right: every week the girls in Zedelgem take dance lessons together. Promptly they show their skills to a tune from K3. According to their parents, the children have a lot in common. For starters, they have energy for four - duracellekes , Papa Bart calls them laughing. "They both love dancing, gymnastics and ballet," he says. "It's two nimble ladies."During the conversation, the girls switch princess costumes a few times. 'That fondling with princesses is of course typical at that age', says Bart, 'but it is still striking how proud they behave. Indian women dress very striking and colorful, wear beautiful bracelets and jewelry. Wine and Teena like nothing better than to walk around dressed up. They weren't even four when they wanted earrings.' Sister NyssaCan Teena and Wine remember anything about the orphanage where their close bond grew? “That Sister Nyssa didn't let us cry,” Teena says. But according to her mother, she heard that. 'After six months, young adopted children have forgotten everything about their former environment. The new experiences here are also so overwhelming. What Teena does know, she has from photographs.' It is certain that the Indian girls will forever remain two hands on one stomach. 'Next year they can choose who they are in the class with, and then they will undoubtedly choose each other', says mom Conny.

.

Human traffickers sell children to paedophiles (Germany, Haiti)

Human traffickers sell children to paedophiles

Published: 15 Apr 11 10:29 CET

Online: http://www.thelocal.de/society/20110415-34415.html

Share An international band human traffickers has been caught smuggling children to Germany from Haiti and beyond, then selling them to paedophiles, officials said Friday. The group allegedly posed as an aid organisation, luring the children with promises of a better life.

Frédéric Prinz von Anhalt and Zsa Zsa Gabor want a baby (15 Apr 11)

Police look into children with obscure IDs

Police look into children with obscure IDs

10:52, April 14, 2011

Email | Print | Subscribe | Comments | Forum

The Ministry of Public Security is carrying out a six-month inquiry to learn who certain children with obscure identities are and will hold the leaders of the local police departments accountable if child abductions occur, the ministry said on Tuesday.

As part of a six-month campaign that began that day, local police will conduct DNA tests on children who have unknown identities and, to learn whether they have been abducted, compare the results with information contained in a national anti-trafficking DNA database, said Vice-Minister Zhang Xinfeng in a video conference on Tuesday.

Association Meeting for Crèche (orphanage) Directors

13 Apr 2011
Association Meeting for Crèche (orphanage) Directors
Posted by Dixie

21
Share
(sorry this is so long, but there is a lot of information and I feel strongly about some of these issues!)

There are more than 100 registered orphanages that are licensed for international adoptions in Haiti. Orphanages that are licensed for adoptions are called Crèches. We only had about 15 orphanages represented at the meeting. You would think that all crèche directors would be interested in influencing the new adoption law since it is going to affect them a lot. I was the only foreigner at the meeting. I think that is really sad that more directors will not take the time to come and voice what they think about this law.

Each law in Haiti must be voted on and passed by the House of Deputies and the Senate. Then it becomes law after passed and published. We went through the proposed law that was voted on and passed by the Deputies here in Haiti. We looked at each and every article in the law. There was a lot of discussion and we compared what was voted on with the law that was first proposed. There are some problems with this law. Errors that need to be corrected. Some of the wording is not acceptable but when you go back to the original proposed law, this law seems to be much better.

The association is inviting all of the Senators to a reception next week at a local restaurant/hotel to present the changes we would like to see in the proposed law. Many of the Senators are new and might know very little about adoptions. We want to educate them BEFORE they take the law to a vote. We want them to understand what adoptions mean to all of the relinquished orphans in Haiti. We also want them to understand that licensed orphanages are following a legal process and we must follow that process for a legal adoption.

The second thing the association will do is hold a press conference and educate the Haitian public about orphanages and adoptions. The public here believes whatever they hear on the radio. UNICEF, Save the Children, IBESR are not afraid to go to the press. They release information to journalists continually. They go on the radio trying to win over the public to their cause. We must do the same. We have to educate the public to realize that sometimes adoption is the answer for a child’s situation. None of us think that every time adoption is the best answer. But if nothing works to keep the family unified, it should be considered. And the public in Haiti needs to know what adoption really means. Many of our parents that come to the orphanage have been told stories by their neighbors and friends and think what they have been told is the absolute truth no matter what we tell them!

Some good things in the law if the Senate doesn’t change them:

1. A couple must be married 5 years if not married, then have lived together as a couple for 10 years. (the law does not mention age)

2. If one member of a couple is over 30 years old, then it says they can adopt without length of marriage being a problem. (we think this part will be changed and we want it to read if there is documented infertility. None of the directors were in favor of a newly married couple adopting.)

3. NOTHING IS MENTIONED ABOUT NUMBER OF CHILDREN IN A FAMILY!!!! It just says priority consideration is given to couples with no biological children, but if a couple has biological children then children over 8 years old within the family must give their consent to their parents adopting another child. (LET’S PRAY THIS IS LEFT IN!)

4. Single women and men can adopt if they are widowed or divorced and at least 35 years old. (We are going to ask the senators to change this to read SINGLE, WIDOWED, OR DIVORCED)

We need to pray that the law isn’t changed too much and only improved in places. If the Senators change anything, the proposed law then needs to go back into the House of Deputies to vote on the changes made.

There is an urgency about making the associations’ wishes known to the senators because the talk is that they will be voting sometime in May! May is not very far away and we have a lot of things to do in very little time.

We also need to educate the Senators and Deputies about the Hague Convection and what it would mean to Haiti and adoptions. I am afraid that UNICEF will push the Haitian government to ratify the convention without being prepared for the changes required by Haitian Social Services. Haiti is still very much in recovery from the earthquake and there is no way we can prepare for the Hague regulations yet!

It took the USA 10 years to get ready to ratify the Hague. Haiti needs more than a few months! It would be a disaster if they ratified it before they are ready.

Pray for wisdom for Haitian Senators and Deputies for all things but especially for the proposed Adoption Law and concerning the Hague Convention. I pray they will do their own research and not just accept what UNICEF or even what the association tells them. I also pray they actually think of all of the children in orphanages sitting, waiting, crying, for a “forever” family!

 

One more restriction in the PROPOSED Adoption Law that I forgot to mention….

Posted by Dixie

The proposed law does state that no one over 50 years old can adopt.  If one partner of the couple is over 50, then they cannot adopt.  The association is going to propose that this article be changed to read that at least one of the couple must be under 50 years old.  If the couple is older than 50 then they can adopt an older child.   There are too many couple wanting to adopt where one partner is over 50 and the other partner might be 35 or 40.  They should still be allowed to adopt.

We will just have to wait and see if this will change.

A Consultation on Definitions of Formal Care for Children: An Invitation to Participate

A Consultation on Definitions of Formal Care for Children: An Invitation to Participate

http://www.crin.org/docs/Definitions for Formal Care.doc

 Author: BCN, Save the Children, EveryChild, ISS Geneva, and SOS Kinderdorf International

Date: Wednesday, April 13, 2011

 

Imagine Adoption charges a relief: family

Imagine Adoption charges a relief: family

Posted: Apr 11, 2011 8:47 AM AT 

Last Updated: Apr 11, 2011 8:55 PM AT

 

Adoption groups and would-be parents are welcoming charges against the original management of Imagine Adoption.

Former general manager Rick Hayhow and founder Susan Hayhow were arrested Thursday. Waterloo Police and the RCMP have charged them with breach of trust, six counts of fraud over $5,000, and three counts of fraud under $5,000. Each is facing one additional charge of fraud over $5,000.

The charges relate to around $420,000 of funds that allegedly were misused for personal vacations, clothing and renovations to the couple's Cambridge, Ont. home.

The Ontario-based international adoption company went bankrupt in 2009, leaving the adoption process of at least 350 families across Canada in limbo. It was restructured with the help of donations from prospective adopters, including at least seven families from P.E.I.

Tammy MacKinnon, spokeswoman for the P.E.I. Adoption Coalition, told CBC News Monday the charges were a long time in coming, but families are relieved people are being held accountable for what happened.

'It doesn't help my family'

Brenton Dickieson and his wife have been trying to adopt a child from Ethiopia through Imagine Adoption. "It was obvious to all of us who were involved that there was severe mismanagement and probably crimes involved. I was pleased that there are charges that resulted," he said.

"Sometimes these things don't always come true the way that you would expect them to and having them face penalties for that is good, but it doesn't help my family. And it doesn't help people who have dreams of adopting internationally."

Dickieson said it's sad that this case has caused so much hurt to hundreds of families across Canada and has damaged international adoptions. He still hopes for an Ethiopian adoption to come through.

There were eight families on P.E.I. trying to arrange adoptions through Imagine at the time of the bankruptcy. Two have had matches arranged through the restructured company. They are the legal guardians of children from Ethiopia, and are waiting to hear when they can bring their children to Canada. Four are still waiting, and two have moved on to work with other agencies.

The Hayhows have been released from custody. They are due to appear in court again May 26.

Minister asks Adoption Authority to assess situation in Vietnam

Minister asks Adoption Authority to assess situation in Vietnam

THE MINISTER FOR CHILDREN Frances Fitzgerald has asked the Adoption Authority chairman to visit Vietnam to assess how the country has improved its foreign adoption system.

Adoptions from Vietnam to Ireland have been suspended since the bilateral agreement between the two countries lapsed in May 2009 amid international concerns about the circumstances surrounding adoptions from Vietnam.

In February 2010, an International Social Service report commissioned by UNICEF Vietnam and the Vietnamese government found that inter-country adoptions from Vietnam were “essentially influenced by foreign demand”, meaning the number of children available for adoption was more related to the number of prospective adopters than the needs of the children.

It added: