Home  

Mom questions China's adoption system

 

Mom questions China's adoption system

 

 

 
 
 

A Nova Scotia mother who adopted a baby from China says she is haunted by questions about whether her little girl -- and other Chinese adoptees in Canada -- might have been kidnapped from her birth parents, or sold for cash.

"I'm very, very scared," says Cathy Wagner, who wants the federal government to stop all Canadian adoptions from China until fears about the true origins of orphans there can be properly investigated.

This week the Los Angeles Times published explosive evidence that Chinese babies, particularly those in rural villages, had been kidnapped from their parents and sold to orphanages by corrupt adoption officials cashing in on the vast sums of money made available by the foreign demand for Chinese children.

The newspaper also said local authorities had tricked or coerced Chinese families into giving up newborns for adoption, only to sell those children to orphanages.

The paper quoted parents in the provinces of Guizhou and Hunan who said their babies had been stolen, sold, and adopted overseas in recent years.

The Chinese government levies fines against families that have multiple children, but it is illegal to seize a child without the parents' consent, or to buy and sell babies.

Wagner, who adopted a baby girl from China's Chongqing province in 2006, says she doesn't know if her child was kidnapped, or properly placed for adoption by its parents. But her own experience, of travelling to China to receive her daughter, left her with uncomfortable questions.

"I would be heartbroken (if she was stolen)," says Wagner, who lives in Bridgewater, N.S. "A mother's worst fear is that: 'I'm going to find out that I victimized another woman.' I don't want to find that. I also don't want to find out that an orphanage paid for my daughter. It's wrong. It's trafficking either way.

"I don't think us adoptive parents should ever have been put in this position. I think it's our federal government's responsibility to make sure this stops. We shouldn't be sitting here wondering and wanting to know, and we shouldn't be worried that our children were stolen."

When Wagner and her husband first applied to adopt, she says she naively accepted the assurances of adoption officials in Nova Scotia that China's system was legally operated and free of corruption.

The family received government approval for the adoption of a baby girl, and was instructed to make a donation to the Chinese orphanage of $3,000 US cash, in crisp, new $100 bills.

That money was officially meant to reimburse the orphanage for the cost of clothing, feeding and caring for the baby until new parents could be found. However, Wagner says their baby hadn't been well cared for, and had suffered what she calls "severe deprivation" at the centre.

Wagner says according to the orphanage's own information, it would have earned nearly $1.5-million US between 2004 and 2006 in similar adoption "fees." But Wagner says there was little evidence that the money was being spent on children.

More than 80,000 Chinese children have been adopted overseas since 1990. Each year about 1,000 of those children are adopted in Canada. And there are about 30,000 foreign families still waiting for Chinese babies.

Wagner says this insatiable foreign demand, and the cash that accompanies it, not only makes it difficult for Chinese couples to compete for adoptive children in their own country, it also fuels a corrupt system that now appears to involve the kidnapping of babies.

The Chinese Center for Adoption Affairs, the government agency responsible for foreign adoptions, declined to comment on the Los Angeles Times investigation. The agency's officials have told foreign diplomats adoption abuses were limited, and no longer occur.

Wagner says it's difficult for foreign governments -- and virtually impossible for Canada's provinces, which oversee incoming foreign adoptions -- to investigate the system in China.

A spokesman for the Department of Foreign Affairs said Friday that foreign adoptions by Canadians are not the department's responsibility. The Department of Citizenship and Immigration, which grants citizenship to foreign adoptees, did not respond to requests for comments.

Wrong move wipes out identity

Wrong move wipes out identity

PHILIP Choong Kim Hoong rides a bicycle to work every day. The hawker has to make the one kilometre trip three or four times a day from his house. If it rains, his goods will get wet and if it pours, he has to take the day off.

When the weather is bad, he wishes he had a car, but that is wishful thinking. He can't get a driving licence because he does not possess an identity card or MyKad.

Choong, 28, may have a Chinese name but he is actually Indian. He was adopted at birth by a Chinese family who listed themselves as birth parents in his birth certificate.

It is for this very reason that the National Registration Department confiscated his birth certificate when he applied for an identity card at the age of 12.

In limbo after easy adoption

Sunday May 23, 2010

In limbo after easy adoption

By RASHVINJEET S.BEDI
sunday@thestar.com.my

It may be a fast route to adopt a baby illegally. But in the long run, the price to pay is very high, especially when the child grows up to be stateless and helpless.

WHEN *Peter Lau and his wife could not have a baby after two years of trying, they decided to adopt. They had tried various conception methods but none of them produced any results.

Ombudsman says foreign adoptions suspended

Ombudsman says foreign adoptions suspended

21.05.2010, 04.04

 

NALCHIK, May 21 (Itar-Tass) -- Russian ombudsman for children’s rights Pavel Astakhov confirmed on Thursday that foreign adoptions had been suspended in the country until bilateral agreements are signed to protect the children.

“Foreign adoption of Russian children has been de-facto suspended,” he told reporters, adding de-jure decision has not been passed so far.

“According to the Family Code, foreign adoption is a temporary and exclusive measure related to children who cannot be adopted in Russia which is allowed only on the basis of bilateral international agreements,” Astakhov said adding such an agreement with the United States would resolve the legal adoption collision.

“Otherwise over 70 thousand earlier adopted children in the United States will be outlawed,” he said.

http://www.itar-tass.com/eng/level2.html?NewsID=15148629&PageNum=0

 

Adoption struggle: One woman's emotional road

Adoption struggle: One woman's emotional road

  Reported by: Kristin Lowman
Email: kristinlowman@fox23news.com
Videographer: B. Sanders
Editor: B. Sanders
Last Update: 4:22 am
Video 1 of 1
Adoption Struggles 
Adoption Struggle
To most, it would appear one local business owner had it all; a successful spa, great friends and family. But one thing was missing from Anita Hug's life -- a child of her own.

Her journey took her overseas to adopt, and she overcame major obstacles to find the love of her life.

Watching Anita and Phiza Hug, they look like any other mother and daughter, but it wasn't always this way.

Anita Hug said, "She wasn't eating for me, sleeping for me, her eyes were dead. There was just no life to her."

It's been seven months since Anita brought Phiza to the U.S. from India. But getting Phiza home wasn't easy. Anita's intercountry adoption was like a roller coaster.

When asked if she thought at some point she wouldn't bring her home, Hug answered, "Yes, I remember calling and thinking I had been robbed of $30,000."

$30,000 was the amount of the loan Anita took out for the process.

Thousands for the adoption itself-- thousands more for the paperwork.

Some forms were hundreds of dollars each and the home studies took months.

Anita's search for a child started in Guatamala, but when the adoption was being finalized adoptions in the country shut down.

Which brought Anita to India and to Phiza.

Photos started coming to the U.S. and Anita finally saw her daughter.

Then another disaster when the Indian orphanage lost it's license. Adoptions were put on hold until the facility was reinstated.

Hug said, "I got to the point where I was holding a picture of a child I thought would never be mine."

After more than a year of waiting and more pictures, Anita finally went to India to pick up her daughter. Thats when another battle began.

Hug said, "Uou wait your whole life for this moment and she wouldn't hug me. I would walk into the room and scream and cry. I thought I made the biggest mistake of my life and thought what have I done."

But slowly Phiza came around. Now, the child who wasn't allowed outside and survived on bananas and water, smiles, laughs, openly gives kisses.

She's learned English in only a few months, picked up on American culture, while her mom realizes all of those hardships were worth it.

Hug said, "I was meant to have her. She was supposed to be with me. These kids need homes and its hard to know they could be there until someone has the courage to do it. I'm lucky to have her. I thank God every day."

For more information on International adoptions or intercountry adoption visit http://adoption.state.gov/adoption.homepage.html

For adopting in New York State visit http://www.ocfs.state.ny.us/adopt/.

http://www.fox23news.com/news/local/story/Adoption-struggle-One-womans-emotional-road/aD6RycWScUmjmArHDxAr4A.cspx

 

Escalation of Child Trafficking in China

Escalation of Child Trafficking in China Authorities show little concern

By Zhang Anli & Yu Liang
Sound of Hope Radio Network
Created: Dec 6, 2009 Last Updated: Dec 7, 2009

Child Trafficking in China
Wang Bangyin breaks down as he hugs his rescued son in Guiyang, southwest China on October 29, 2009. His son was among the 60 children rescued from human traffickers. (STR/AFP/Getty Images)

 

The Supreme People’s Court recently disclosed that two men were executed Nov. 26 for abducting and selling children. Parents victimized by such crimes say the executions serve only to appease public sentiment.

The trafficking of children has been escalating sharply in recent years, arousing widespread public anger and frustration throughout China, according to a Sound of Hope radio report. Every year thousands of children—primarily those of poor farmers and migrant workers—are abducted and sold.

Concerned parents of kidnapped children argue that punishing traffickers alone will not benefit the abducted children: The regime must take effective steps to stem the tide of the booming black market, and punish not only the traffickers, but the buyers as well.

Police indifference

Mr. Chen, the father of a missing child from Xi’an, the capital of Shaanxi Province, said that the local police are often indifferent and callous when confronted with a missing-child case.

“The government has not done enough to combat kidnapping,” Chen said. “I do not think punishing a few traffickers is going to work. The relative of a missing child told me that he found a trafficker living in his neighborhood. He submitted a claim, but the police did nothing.

“Do you know that it was only for the sake of appearances that those two traffickers were sentenced to death?” Chen asked. “In order to appease public sentiment, the government decided to kill two traffickers this time. I know that’s why they did it.”

A buyer’s market

Mr. Peng, the father of a kidnapped child from Shenzhen City, Guangdong Province, thinks that those who buy children are at the root of the problem. If they are not punished, he said, the selling of stolen children will become even more professional, organized, and violent.

“Some people are driven by greed and will risk committing a crime for the money,” Peng said. “A 3 to 5-year-old boy can be sold for as much as 40,000 to 50,000 yuan (US$5,888–$7,352). Without the buyer’s market, nobody would be engaged in stealing or kidnapping children.”

A woman from Hebei Province who asked to remain anonymous said she has been trying to find her child for the past 15 years, and during that time, more and more children have disappeared. She hopes that punishments will be strengthened for both the traffickers and the buyers.

“If the government does not take concrete steps to stop the problem, more and more parents across the country will lose their children, as I have,” she said.

The Chinese regime estimates the number of children involved to be 10,000 a year. The U.S. State Department’s Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, however, estimates that there are 20,000 to 70,000 victims of child trafficking each year in China.

Yang Zaixin, a lawyer from Guangxi Province, noted that the trafficking of women and children is illegal in China, but buyers have rarely been punished in accordance with the law. He also said that the trafficking of children is just one of the critical social issues facing Chinese society today.

Read original Chinese article: http://soundofhope.org/programs/162/144114-1.asp

http://www.theepochtimes.com/n2/content/view/26115/

 

As Profitable as the Drug Trade

05/21/2010

 

As Profitable as the Drug Trade

China's Child-Trafficking Epidemic

By Andreas Lorenz in Beijing

Sex-obsessed culture, lack of social services blamed for rise in human trafficking at Fort Worth

Sex-obsessed culture, lack of social services blamed for rise in human trafficking at Fort Worth forum

12:00 AM CDT on Friday, May 21, 2010

By JASON TRAHAN / The Dallas Morning News

jtrahan@dallasnews.com

FORT WORTH – An increasingly sexualized consumer society and inadequate funding for social services are major reasons why more young girls are being pressed into sexual slavery, a human-trafficking expert told a Fort Worth audience Thursday.

Jane's Blog: Minnesota Adoption Factsheet- 2007 data - TAX IT

Tax it.Posted on May 21, 2010 by jjtrenka

Minnesota Adoption Factsheet- 2007 data

Children’s Home Society and Family Services Annual Report 2007-2008 (based in Minnesota)

In 2007 –

There were 1,526 foster children in Minnesota waiting to be adopted.

Blog: Treatment Aronson promotes Federici's therapy

See: After 30 minutes or so of extracting our personal histories, she announced that our problems with Peter, and mine in particular, were a direct result of my not having sufficiently grieved over my miscarriages and infertility, as well as the loss of Ben, the baby we turned down in Russia.

October 15, 2007 and Chapter 22

Filed under: Dr. Federici,FAS,Jane Aronson,Post-Institutional,Russian Adoption,Special Needs Adoption,attachment,fetal alcohol syndrome,international adoption,learning disabled,orphan — whenrainhurts @ 5:15 pm

Tags: adoption, international adoption, autism, Dr. Jane Aronson, Dr. Ronald Federici, fetal alcohol, post-institutional autism, suzanne d'aversa, Hansen, "Russian boy"

Apple Picking (October 2007)